Email Marketing

Donor-Centric Messaging in Email Fundraising

Most fundraising emails are about the organization. The ones that work are about the donor and the person they can help. Here's how to tell the difference and how to rewrite an email so the donor has a part in it.

Shortly after I joined Food for the Hungry, I moved our email fundraising from an expensive outside agency to our own team. I expected revenue to improve. At first, the improvement was disappointing.

When I read what we were sending, I could see why. Our team was new to this, and our appeals emphasized our programs and how effective the organization was. The donor had no part in the story.

We learned to make the donor the central participant. That's what donor-centric messaging means, and email is where it shows most clearly. Here's how to do it. For the rest of your program, see the guide to nonprofit email marketing.

What it is

A donor-centric email is written from where the donor sits. It answers three questions the donor has:

  • Who needs help?
  • What can I do about it?
  • What will happen if I do?

An organization-centered email answers different questions: What do we do? How well do we do it? What do we need?

I think of the donor as the hero of the story. Your organization is how they get to help.

How to spot the problem

Count the pronouns. Mark every "we," "our" and "us." Then mark every "you" and "your." If the first group is larger, the email is about you.

Look at the subjects of your sentences. "We delivered 500 meals." "Our staff trained 30 teachers." "Our program reached four villages." The organization is doing everything.

Read the ask. "Support our work" asks the donor to help the organization. "Feed a child this week" asks the donor to help a child.

Before and after

Before:

"This year, our team expanded our tutoring program to three new schools. Thanks to our dedicated staff, we now serve 200 students. We need your support to continue this important work. Please donate today."

After:

"Two hundred students have a tutor this year because of people like you. One of them is Marcus, a fourth-grader who read his first chapter book in March. Forty more kids are on the waiting list. Your gift of $60 gives one of them a tutor for a month. Will you help today?"

The facts are the same. In the second version, the donor did something, can see who it helped and knows what to do next.

Marcus is an example I made up. Use a real person, with permission.

How to rewrite

1. Change who acts. "We provide" becomes "Your gift provides." "Our program reaches" becomes "You reach."

2. Put a person in it. One name and one detail.

3. Replace organizational needs with human ones. Not "we need $10,000." What does the $10,000 do, and for whom?

4. Make the ask specific. An amount, a result and a date.

5. Thank them for what they've already done. Before you ask again, say what their last gift accomplished.

At Food for the Hungry, we once had a very young writer on staff, and I said on a call that it might be hard for someone that young to write for our older donors. My boss corrected me. Putting themselves in the donor's shoes is the writer's job, he said. Whoever writes your emails, that's the job.

Keep it true

Donor-centric doesn't mean exaggerated. "Your $25 saved a life" is rarely accurate. "Your $25 provided a week of meals" probably is. Donors trust the second kind of sentence, and trust is what brings the next gift.

It also means listening. Ask donors what they hope their giving does, and write to them about that.

Common mistakes

  • Opening with the organization's news
  • Thanking staff more than donors
  • Using inside language donors don't use
  • Burying the ask
  • Sending only appeals, with no reports on what gifts did

Where to start this week

Take your next email before it goes out. Count the "we"s and the "you"s. Rewrite the first three sentences so a person your work helps and the donor are the ones acting. Then send the old version to half your list and the new one to the other half, and compare.

For the same idea applied to appeals, see stop telling donors what you need.

Questions fundraisers ask

What is donor-centric messaging?

Writing from the donor's point of view. It shows a person who needs help, tells the donor what their gift will do and makes the donor the one who acts. The organization appears as the way the gift reaches that person.

How do I know if my email is donor-centric?

Count the pronouns. If "we," "our" and "us" appear more often than "you" and "your," the email is about the organization. Then ask what the reader is being asked to do and why it matters to them.

Does donor-centric mean flattering the donor?

No. It means giving the donor an accurate picture of a need and of what their gift will do. Overstating a gift's effect is a way of misleading donors, and they notice.

Can a newsletter be donor-centric?

Yes, and it should be. Report results as things donors made possible. "Because you gave, 40 children started school" tells the same news as "Our program enrolled 40 children."

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggeddonor centricemailemail fundraisingherostorytelling

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside