Donor Communication
Nonprofit Fundraising Benchmarks (Updated for 2026)
Current nonprofit fundraising benchmarks for donor retention, the second gift, average gift, email, monthly giving and more, with the source for each.

Benchmarks tell you whether your results are normal, strong or worth worrying about. Is a 45% donor retention rate good? Is $114 a typical online gift? You can't answer those questions without something to compare against.
Below are the most useful nonprofit fundraising benchmarks available as of late 2026, grouped by topic, with the source for each. Most describe calendar year 2025. Where a figure covers 2026 so far, it says so.
How to use these benchmarks
- Compare like with like. Benchmarks from large national organizations won't match a small local nonprofit. Look for the closest comparison, and pay more attention to direction than to exact numbers.
- Know the source. Each report has its own panel. Virtuous reports on its own customers, which may run a little higher than the sector. M+R's panel leans toward advocacy and national groups.
- Compare yourself with yourself first. Your own trend over three years tells you more than any industry average.
- Use them to ask questions, not to grade yourself. A number below the benchmark is a reason to look closer, not proof that something is broken.
Overall giving
Metric | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
Total U.S. giving, 2025 | $617.2 billion, up 5.7% (3.0% after inflation) | Giving USA 2026 |
Giving by individuals | $394.2 billion, 64% of the total, up 4.1% | Giving USA 2026 |
Giving by foundations | $117.15 billion, up 5.7% | Giving USA 2026 |
Giving by bequest | $62.19 billion, up 19.7% | Giving USA 2026 |
Giving by corporations | $43.67 billion, up 3.1% | Giving USA 2026 |
Giving to religion | $151.58 billion, 23% of all giving | Giving USA 2026 |
Change in number of donors, 2025 | Down 3.6%, the fifth straight year of decline | Fundraising Effectiveness Project, Q4 2025 |
The headline: more dollars, fewer donors. Total giving set a record, but fewer people are giving, and more of the money is coming from larger gifts.
Donor retention and the second gift
Metric | All sectors | Faith-based | Top quarter |
|---|---|---|---|
Overall donor retention | 54.73% | 61.29% | 69.6% |
First-time donors who give a second gift | 25.84% | 32.63% | 37.9% |
Days to the second gift | 108.5 | 106 | |
Gifts per donor per year | 4.15 | 4.68 | 6.62 |
Five-year donor lifetime value | $2,234 | $2,383 |
Sources: Virtuous 2026 Nonprofit Benchmark Report (771 organizations) and Virtuous and Masterworks 2026 Faith-Based Nonprofit Benchmark Report (173 organizations), both for calendar year 2025.
For a sector-wide view, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project put full-year 2025 donor retention at 43.3%. The difference from Virtuous mostly reflects who is in each panel.
The number to watch is the second gift. About three of four new donors never give again. Here's how to improve donor retention.
Gift size
Metric | All sectors | Faith-based | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Average gift | $136.00 | $141.96 | Virtuous 2026 |
Median gift | $50 | $50 | Virtuous 2026 |
Average online gift | $114.90 | $108.41 | Virtuous 2026 |
Revenue per active donor (mid-year 2026) | $229 | RKD Group 2026 Mid-Year Benchmark |
Online and email
Metric | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
Online revenue growth, 2025 | Up 15% | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Email revenue per subscriber | $2.40 (up from $1.87) | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Welcome series click rate | 1.6%, against 0.59% for standard fundraising email | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Online revenue arriving in December | 37% | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Online revenue on December 31 alone | 4% | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Digital ad spend | About 10 cents per $1 of online revenue | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Share of all revenue in December | About 18% | Blackbaud Institute |
Here's how to build an email fundraising program and 21 digital fundraising KPIs to track.
Monthly giving
Metric | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
Monthly donors still active after a year | 71%, against 24% of new one-time donors | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Retention of recurring donors | 81%, against 46% for single-gift donors | Blackbaud donorCentrics, FY24 |
Monthly giving's share of online revenue | 27% | M+R Benchmarks 2026 |
Recurring share of revenue | 20.96% all sectors, 25.22% faith-based, 44% top quarter | Virtuous 2026 |
Here's the guide to monthly giving.
Planned giving
Metric | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
Bequest giving, 2025 | $62.2 billion, up 19.7% | Giving USA 2026 |
Real growth over five years | 20.7% for bequests, 10.4% for giving overall | Giving USA 2026 |
Here's the guide to planned giving.
Giving Tuesday
Metric | Benchmark | Source |
|---|---|---|
Raised in the U.S., 2025 | $4.0 billion, up 13% | GivingTuesday Data Commons |
Participants, 2025 | 38.1 million | GivingTuesday Data Commons |
2026 so far
- Revenue growth is slowing. First-quarter revenue grew 4.3% in 2026, after 5.4% in 2025 and 10.4% in 2024 (Fundraising Effectiveness Project, Q1 2026).
- Donor counts are falling more slowly. Down 0.8% in the first quarter of 2026, against 2.3% a year earlier, though new donor counts kept falling (FEP, Q1 2026).
- Fewer donors are giving more. RKD Group's 219 direct response organizations had their best first half in ten years, $1.86 billion, from their fewest active donors in seven (RKD 2026 Mid-Year Benchmark).
- A new deduction most donors don't know about. Starting in 2026, people who don't itemize can deduct cash gifts to operating charities, up to $1,000 for single filers and $2,000 for married couples filing jointly. Three of four donors don't know it exists (Dunham+Company, February 2026).
Where to find more
These reports are worth reading in full each year:
- Giving USA, the annual report on U.S. philanthropy
- Fundraising Effectiveness Project quarterly reports, for donor counts and retention
- M+R Benchmarks, for online, email and digital advertising
- Virtuous Nonprofit Benchmark Report, for retention, the second gift and lifetime value
- Blackbaud Institute, for giving trends and recurring giving
- RKD Group benchmark reports, for direct response organizations
Benchmarks are most useful when they feed your plan. Your 12-Month Fundraising Plan in One Day walks you through turning your numbers into next year's goals.
Questions fundraisers ask
What is a good donor retention rate?
Overall retention averaged 54.73% in the Virtuous 2026 report and 43.3% in the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 data. Above 60% is strong for most organizations.
What percentage of first-time donors give again?
About one in four. In the Virtuous 2026 report, 25.84% of first-time donors made a second gift, and the top quarter of organizations converted 37.9%.
What is the average online gift to a nonprofit?
$114.90 across all sectors in the Virtuous 2026 report, with a median gift of $50.
Where can I find nonprofit fundraising benchmarks?
Giving USA, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project, M+R Benchmarks, the Virtuous benchmark reports, the Blackbaud Institute and RKD Group all publish them, most once a year.
Ask a fundraiser




