Planned Giving

Why Some Donors Are Reluctant to Discuss Planned Giving

Many loyal donors change the subject when estate plans come up. The reasons are usually personal and reasonable. Here's what's behind the reluctance and how to respond.

I know of a large nonprofit with a dedicated team of planned giving experts. My understanding is that they know in advance about only around 25% of the estate gifts that eventually arrive.

The other three-quarters come from donors who never said a word. Many people don't want to disclose their estate plans, and that's their choice.

So when a loyal donor changes the subject, it doesn't mean they aren't interested. It may mean they've already done it. Here's why donors hesitate and what to do. For the basics, see the guide to planned giving.

Why donors hesitate

It means thinking about death. A conversation about a will is a conversation about not being here. Many people put it off for years.

Family comes first. Donors worry that a gift to charity takes from their children or grandchildren. Some worry about how the family will react.

It's private. Many people consider their estate nobody's business but their own.

It seems complicated. They picture attorneys, trusts and fees.

They're afraid of pressure. They worry that once they tell you, the calls will start, or that you'll ask how much.

They think they don't have enough. Many faithful donors of modest means assume legacy giving is for the wealthy.

They might change their mind. They don't want to make a promise they'd have to take back.

Each of these is reasonable. None of them is about you.

How to respond

Start with their story. Ask how they came to care about the work and what they hope it will be doing in twenty years. Let the future come up naturally.

Say that family comes first. "Most people take care of family first and leave a small percentage to causes they love."

Keep it simple. "For most people it's one sentence in a will, or one form for a retirement account."

Say it can be changed. "You can change it any time. It isn't a pledge."

Promise not to pressure, and keep the promise. "I'll never ask you the amount, and you never have to tell us."

Let them decide in private. Give them a one-page summary with your legal name and tax ID, and suggest they talk with their attorney or advisor.

Let silence be an answer. Early in my career I kept talking after an ask until the donor interrupted me. He'd already decided. In a legacy conversation, ask your question and give the donor room.

When the answer is "not now"

A generous donor once told me they cared about our work but had reached their giving limit for the year, and asked me to come back after the new year. We did, and they made a five-figure gift. The first answer was about timing.

Planned giving is full of "not now." Thank the donor, note when to return and keep the relationship warm in the meantime.

For the donors who will never tell you

Serving Orphans Worldwide once received a substantial estate gift from a man who had never given to us. We had no idea he'd included us. He'd read our website before he decided.

Make that easy:

  • A web page with your legal name, tax ID and sample wording
  • A short mention in every newsletter
  • A checkbox on reply cards: "I've included you in my plans" and "Please send information"
  • A confidential way to let you know

Where to start this week

Think of one loyal donor who changed the subject the last time legacy giving came up. Send a handwritten note thanking them for their years of support, with no mention of it. In six months, ask about their story again.

For the questions to use, see 10 questions to ask donors about planned giving.

Questions fundraisers ask

Why won't donors talk about their wills?

Thinking about a will means thinking about death, and many people put it off. Others consider their estate a private family matter, or worry that telling a charity will lead to pressure.

Should I keep asking if a donor avoids the subject?

Not in the same conversation. Thank them, move on and keep the relationship warm. Mention legacy gifts in your general communications, and raise it again personally in six months or a year.

How do I respect a donor's privacy and still learn about planned gifts?

Offer ways to tell you without a conversation, such as a checkbox on a reply card or a confidential form. Make clear that telling you is optional and that you'll never ask the amount.

What if a donor worries about providing for family?

Agree with them. Family comes first. Many donors leave a small percentage to charity after providing for family, and they can change it at any time.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

TaggedconversationsdonorsfearsPlanned giving

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside