Donor Communication
Nonprofit Email Marketing: A Fundraiser's Guide
How to build a nonprofit email program that raises money: grow your list, reach the inbox, welcome donors, set your cadence and write better appeals.

Email is still where most nonprofits raise the most money online. It's cheap to send, it reaches people who already know you, and it lets you ask, thank and report back without waiting for the next printed appeal.
But email programs fail in quiet ways. Messages land in a promotions tab nobody checks. The list grows while the number of people who read it shrinks. Every email asks, and donors tune out. This guide covers what I've learned running email fundraising at Food for the Hungry, World Concern and Serving Orphans Worldwide: how to build the list, reach the inbox, welcome new people, decide how often to send, write emails that raise money and measure what matters.
Start with the donor, not the organization
Shortly after I joined Food for the Hungry, I moved our email fundraising from an expensive outside agency to an in-house team. The first results were disappointing. Our team was new to fundraising, and the appeals we wrote talked about our programs and how effective the organization was.
Donors didn't respond to that. What they respond to is their own part in the story: the child they can feed, the family they can help, the difference their gift makes this week. Once we rewrote our emails to make the donor the main character, results improved.
That's the foundation for everything below. Read more on donor-centric messaging in email fundraising.
Build a list of people who want to hear from you
Your email list is an asset you own. Social platforms change their rules; your list doesn't. The best way to grow it is to offer something useful in exchange for an email address.
At Food for the Hungry, I wrote a blog series called "7 Ways to Teach Your Kids Generosity." It was popular, so we turned it into an ebook and used it to collect email addresses. Six years after I left, it was still the organization's most popular lead-generation asset, and it had brought in at least tens of thousands of leads.
A good lead magnet solves a problem your audience keeps having, and it keeps working for years. For more ideas, see how to build your nonprofit email list, whether paid lead generation ads are worth it, and how to turn website visitors into subscribers.
Paid placements can work too. At World Concern, two different staff members suggested advertising in the same email newsletter. I didn't think it would work, but I've learned to pay attention when two people independently suggest the same thing. A donation ad in that newsletter cost about $6,000 and netted about $35,000, and we kept using the channel for years.
Size isn't the goal. Engagement is.
One consulting client set a goal of adding a million new leads in a year, and the board watched the size of the list closely. The file was also full of old names that hadn't opened an email in a long time. Cleaning them out would have helped engagement and how mailbox providers saw the sender, but it would also have made the headline number smaller, so they resisted.
A big list isn't the same as a valuable one. A smaller list of people who open, click and give is worth more than a huge file of people who never respond. Plan to reactivate or remove unresponsive addresses at least once a year.
Protect your deliverability
One year at World Concern, our year-end email results came in well below the year before. The content was similar. Our email platform reported about 99 percent deliverability, and our tech team couldn't find a problem.
The results said otherwise. We tested a different email platform, and at the next year-end campaign it performed much better. "Delivered" had only meant the email was accepted, not that it reached a place where a donor would see it.
The lesson cost us real money: when your results and your dashboard disagree, trust the results and investigate. Before your biggest campaigns, check that your emails will reach the inbox.
Welcome every new subscriber and donor
The first few emails after someone joins your list or makes a first gift set the tone for the whole relationship. A welcome series thanks them, tells them what to expect and shows them the work.
Welcome emails are some of the best-performing emails you’ll send. In M+R’s 2026 benchmarks, welcome series emails drew a 1.6 percent click rate, compared with 0.59 percent for standard fundraising emails.
At Food for the Hungry, our email platform and donation system didn't talk to each other at first. When we finally connected them, it would have been easy to stall on everything a full welcome series was supposed to include. Instead, I automated one welcome email and got it working. Then we added a second, a third, a fourth and a fifth.
If you don't have a welcome series yet, don't wait until you can build the whole thing. Automate one email this month. Here are nine emails you can send in your welcome series, and a version written for new givers at a church.
How often to email your donors
There's no universal right number. An international charity can reasonably email more often than a local private school. Watch what your donors do instead of guessing: rising unsubscribes, too many asks compared with impact stories, or donors who stop giving by email are signs you're asking too often.
At Serving Orphans Worldwide, our usual month has four emails:
- A letter from me with a very soft ask.
- A newsletter focused on impact stories.
- An impact story email.
- A fundraising email.
That rhythm lets donors see what their giving does before we ask again. For the newsletter, see how to create email newsletters that inform and inspire and the question every newsletter should be able to answer: if you stopped sending it, would anyone notice?
Write emails that raise money
A fundraising email has a few jobs: get opened, get read and get a click to give. These posts take each part in turn:
- The subject line. How to write fundraising email subject lines, plus 500 real subject lines to spark ideas.
- The story. How to move from story to ask.
- The ask. How to write a fundraising email, the call to action and honest urgency.
- The format. Emails that read well on a phone and when to use video.
Two habits help more than any single tactic. Write to one person, in plain words, about one need. And test your assumptions instead of trusting conventions. In my own testing, a story has consistently beaten a statistic.
Build relationships, not just campaigns
Email isn't only for asking. Thank donors, report what their gifts did and invite them closer. That's how email helps you build donor relationships and keep the donors you worked to find. It also opens the door to bigger conversations, such as inviting donors to consider a legacy gift.
Different audiences need different approaches. See email marketing to engage younger donors and, if your budget is tight, email marketing on a shoestring.
Measure what matters
Open rates are less reliable than they used to be, because some email apps load images automatically. Focus on the numbers closer to giving: clicks, gifts, revenue per email sent, unsubscribes and how many new subscribers make a first gift. Then use your data to decide what to change.
For context, M+R’s 2026 benchmarks put email revenue at about $2.40 per subscriber in 2025, up from $1.87 the year before. Compare your own number against your past results first, and against benchmarks second.
And keep the reporting honest. If one department gets credit for a donor that another channel found, the channel that's working can look like it's failing and lose its budget.
Plan your year
Most online giving happens at year-end, so build your email calendar early. See how to write year-end fundraising emails and the month-by-month guide to year-end fundraising.
If you want a step-by-step plan for your whole email program, the Nonprofit Email Marketing course walks you through it. When you're ready to show what you know, the Certified Nonprofit Email Marketer (CNEM) credential comes with a free study guide and practice exam.
Questions fundraisers ask
How often should a nonprofit email its donors?
There's no universal number. Watch unsubscribes, giving and the balance of asks to impact stories. Serving Orphans Worldwide usually sends four emails a month: a letter with a soft ask, a newsletter, an impact story and one fundraising email.
What should a nonprofit welcome series include?
Start with one automated welcome or thank-you email. Then add emails that show the work, tell a story and invite a next step, one at a time.
Why are my email results down when deliverability looks fine?
A platform can report an email as delivered even when it lands somewhere donors don't look. If your results and your dashboard disagree, investigate inbox placement.
Ask a fundraiser




