Monthly Giving

How to Start a Monthly Giving Program

How to start a monthly giving program that grows: getting buy-in, naming it, setting gift levels, finding your first 100 donors and keeping them.

A monthly giving program is a named, organized way for donors to give automatically every month. You may also hear it called a recurring giving program or a sustainer program. A real program is more than a checkbox on your donation form. It has a name, a standard gift amount, a welcome for every new donor and a plan to keep them. Recurring giving keeps growing as donors get used to subscriptions, so this is a good time to start.

When I was at World Concern, our monthly donor program grew from about 800 donors to more than 4,000 over a few years. No single tactic did that. It took a named program people wanted to join, better ways to find new monthly donors, a real welcome for every one of them, and a lot of patient work to keep them.

It was worth it. Monthly donors are the most loyal donors most nonprofits will ever have. At Food for the Hungry, multi-year renewal among our monthly donors rose from the 60s to the high 80s percent, and World Concern's was about 88% when I left. Monthly donors also give more than their monthly gift. At Food for the Hungry, they averaged 14.1 gifts a year, about two gifts beyond their twelve monthly ones, mostly at year end.

The benchmarks agree. In M+R’s 2026 study, 71 percent of monthly donors were still giving a year later, compared with 24 percent of new one-time donors. Blackbaud’s donorCentrics data shows the same gap: 81 percent retention for recurring donors against 46 percent for single-gift donors.

Here's how to start a monthly giving program, or fix one that isn't growing, in eleven steps.

1. Get buy-in before you build anything

The biggest obstacle to monthly giving is usually inside your own building. Staff worry it will cannibalize other giving. Program leaders don't see why it needs a budget. I've seen organizations build a program, find a channel that worked, and then have a senior leader cancel it. It's the first of seven monthly giving mistakes that keep programs from growing.

So start with leadership, all the way up to the CEO. Show what monthly donors are worth over five years, not one. A donor who gives $38 a month and stays five years gives more than $2,200, before any extra gifts. Get agreement on the goal, the budget and who owns it before you write a word of copy.

2. Put one person in charge

Most organizations start without a dedicated monthly giving manager, and that's fine. Usually it sits with the marketing or development manager, and a dedicated role comes after the program proves itself. But someone has to own it. Programs run by committee, with no one accountable, tend to stall.

In a small shop, the development director should run point. Someone else can manage the project plan, but an executive needs to keep it moving. A real share of one person's time is the minimum for what can become one of your most powerful sources of revenue.

3. Name your monthly giving program

Don't treat monthly giving as a checkbox on your donation form. Give it a name. When we surveyed donors, they told us they wanted to belong to something and to be part of a community of people who care about the same thing. A named program gives them that, and it helps with both signing people up and keeping them.

Name it after your organization or its core idea. charity: water's monthly program is The Spring. A food pantry might call its monthly donors the Pantry Partners. Keep it short, easy to say and clearly yours. For more ideas, see these 50 monthly giving program names sorted by cause, with how to choose one.

4. Set your monthly giving levels

Pick one standard monthly amount and make it the default. At World Concern, our village sponsorship was $38 a month. The giving form showed $38, double that, and an "other" amount. We encouraged $38 but allowed lower gifts, like $20.

At Food for the Hungry, child sponsorship couldn't be funded below about $39 a month, so we offered multiples of that amount and no lower options. Let what the gift actually funds set your floor.

Tie the amount to something concrete: a child's school year, a family's groceries, a village's clean water. A donor should be able to picture what $38 a month does.

5. Set up your giving page and payments

You don't need special software to start. Most online giving tools already handle recurring gifts, so begin with the one you have. Before you launch, make sure it can do four things:

  • Charge the donor automatically on the same day each month.
  • Let donors update their own card or change their gift without calling you.
  • Tell you right away when a payment fails, so you can start recovering it.
  • Record every gift in your donor database.

Then build a page just for the program. Put the program's name at the top, make monthly the default and show your standard amount first. If your tool supports it, offer bank draft alongside cards. Food for the Hungry and World Concern both accepted monthly gifts by bank draft, and I recommend it. A bank account has no expiration date, and retention on those gifts is high.

Make the confirmation clear. The thank-you page and the receipt should say the gift is monthly, how much it is and when the next charge will come. Cancellations spike at the end of the first month, often because someone didn't realize the gift was monthly.

Finally, test it yourself. At Food for the Hungry, at least once a year I signed up and made a small gift as if I were a new donor. My team joked that every July they'd get a note from me saying something was broken. Sometimes the welcome series never arrived. Looking back, I should have done it at least quarterly. Before you launch, make a monthly gift on your own page and watch what happens next.

6. Find your first 100 monthly donors

You don't need to buy your first 100 monthly donors. Start with the people closest to you:

  • Your board and advisory council. Ask every member to give monthly, even on top of a larger annual gift. They'll receive the stories and updates monthly donors get, which makes them better ambassadors.
  • Your volunteers. Many have the means to give, and they already love the work.
  • Donors who have given more than once but not monthly. These are your best prospects. Call them.

At World Concern, once a year we called donors who had given more than once, with at least about $100 in total giving, and invited them to give monthly. If they said no, we asked whether they'd make one more single gift, and those single gifts often paid for the whole campaign. The calls typically returned about five times what they cost. We used an outside calling firm, which was relatively inexpensive, because most nonprofits don't have experienced callers on staff. Here's more on how to ask donors to give monthly.

Then email your list about the new program, and test small paid ads. One thing I wouldn't count on: direct mail. In my experience, it hasn't worked for converting existing donors to monthly or for finding new monthly donors cold.

Those first 100 donors help fund the next 100, and the next 500.

7. Budget for acquisition

The second big mistake is "build it and they will come." Convenience isn't why people join a monthly program. They join because something moved them. If you have no plan and no budget to reach new people, nobody shows up, and the fundraiser who promised the boss a great program is left explaining why.

Know what a monthly donor really costs. At World Concern, radio was our main acquisition channel, and we assumed each new monthly donor cost about $300. When we did the math correctly, it was closer to $1,000. Radio was still net positive for single-gift donors, but not for monthly donors. So we changed who we went after. For new donors, Christian music artist tours became a great channel. For existing donors, we started the calling campaign above.

Some channels surprise you. Ads in other organizations' email newsletters have brought in monthly donors cold. At World Concern, about 10% of the new donors from those ads came in monthly. At Serving Orphans Worldwide, some newsletter ads bring in up to 20% monthly.

Keep watching the numbers. At SOW, when a source of monthly donors starts drying up and the cost per donor climbs past what we'll pay, we shift those dollars to finding single-gift donors. About 30% of them give a second gift, and they cost roughly an eighth as much to acquire. The math changes, so the plan has to change with it.

8. Welcome every new monthly donor

When I arrived at World Concern, retention was low, largely because there was no real welcome process. We built one. Every new monthly donor got three things:

  • A welcome call from our donor care team.
  • A welcome kit, a letter-size packet about the village they now sponsored, what being a monthly donor means, more about World Concern, and a note affirming their decision.
  • A five-email welcome series, about a week apart, with no ask for money. The emails carried videos, stories of impact and a free resource.

That welcome, along with phone calls and letters to all new donors, is a big part of why our renewal rates rose.

9. Keep them close all year

Monthly donors should feel like insiders. At Food for the Hungry, we started a monthly email newsletter just for sponsors, with stories from the field. Sponsors also got a quarterly mailing with something that helped them connect with their sponsored child. Every monthly donor should get at least one personal update a year: a note from someone they help, a field story or a short video.

Watch for the predictable drop-off points. Cancellations spike at the end of the first month, when the second charge arrives and someone didn't realize it was monthly or a spouse objects. They spike again around month nine. Send something small and meaningful around month seven, like a photo magnet, to head off that second drop. Then check your own cancellation data, because your timing may differ.

10. Recover failed payments

Many monthly donors don't decide to stop giving. Their card expires or the number changes, and the gift quietly fails. Most nonprofits aren't persistent enough about getting it back.

The process we used, first at Food for the Hungry and then at World Concern, ran about 60 days. It started with an email linking to a page where the donor could update their card, then a phone call, then a letter, then postcards, repeating until the donor updated their payment. Many donors fixed it after the first email. The rest needed more touches. Here's how to recover failed monthly gifts step by step.

11. Ask for extra gifts and upgrades, but not too often

Monthly donors will give more than their monthly gift if you ask. I'd ask for an extra gift about once a quarter, plus a bit more at year end, just not every month. Here's more on asking monthly donors for a year-end gift.

Ask for upgrades rarely. In eight years at Food for the Hungry, we asked monthly donors to increase their gift only once. Donors giving $22 to $28 a month were invited to move up to the standard amount of about $38, framed around rising costs in the field, with a page showing the standard amount and its multiples. A good number upgraded. Every couple of years is probably the most you need.

Set a launch date and keep it

The third big mistake is not having a firm timeline. I've seen launches slide for months because the welcome emails never got written. Set a deadline for every piece: the name, the form, the welcome kit, the emails and the first calls. Hold people to it. A good program that launches beats a perfect one that doesn't.

What to expect in the first year

Monthly giving starts small and compounds. One hundred donors at $38 a month is $45,600 a year, and with a real welcome and a failed-payment process, most of them will still be giving next year.

Your first 100 donors can come from your board, your volunteers and your repeat donors, without paid acquisition. There isn't a universal timeline, but if you hustle, you should be able to reach 100 monthly donors in your first 90 days.

After that, growth costs money. Fundraisers I talk with today expect to spend about $300 to acquire a new monthly donor from outside their own file, and some channels cost far more, as we learned with radio at World Concern. Do the math before you promise anyone a number.

What to measure

  • Active monthly donors, and how many you added and lost each month
  • Retention at 3, 12 and 24 months
  • Cost to acquire a monthly donor, by channel
  • Average monthly gift
  • Failed payments, and how many you recovered
  • Extra gifts from monthly donors

More on measuring and improving monthly donor retention, and the benefits of a sustainer program if you still need to make the case internally. If you lead a church, see the guide to recurring giving for churches.

Ready to build yours? The Monthly Giving Masterclass walks you through every step, from naming and branding your program to keeping donors for years.

Questions fundraisers ask

What is a monthly giving program?

A monthly giving program is a named, organized way for donors to give automatically every month. It usually has a name, a standard gift amount, a welcome process and regular updates for the donors who join.

Is monthly giving the same as recurring giving or a sustainer program?

For most nonprofits, yes. Recurring giving can include quarterly or annual gifts, and "sustainer" is another word for a recurring donor, but all three usually describe donors who give automatically each month.

How do I start a monthly giving program?

Get leadership buy-in, put one person in charge, name the program, set a standard monthly amount, and recruit your first donors from your board, volunteers and repeat donors. Then budget for acquisition, welcome every new donor, and have a process to recover failed payments.

What should I name my monthly giving program?

Name it after your organization or its core idea, keep it short, and make it feel like something donors join, like charity: water's The Spring.

How much should a monthly giving level be?

Pick one standard amount tied to something concrete the gift funds, show it as the default with a higher option and an "other" amount, and let what the gift funds set your minimum.

How much does it cost to acquire a monthly donor?

About $300 is what many fundraisers expect today for a donor from outside channels, but check your own math. At World Concern we assumed $300 for radio, and the real cost was closer to $1,000. Calling donors who had already given more than once typically returned about five times what it cost.

What software do I need to start a monthly giving program?

Most online giving tools already handle recurring gifts. Make sure yours charges automatically each month, lets donors update their own card, flags failed payments and records gifts in your donor database.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedmonthlymonthly givingrecurring

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside