Email Marketing
Building Donor Relationships Through Email
Email can do more than ask. Used well, it's how a donor comes to know your organization between gifts. Here's the monthly rhythm we use at Serving Orphans Worldwide and how to build your own.

At Serving Orphans Worldwide, a typical month of email looks like this:
- A president's letter from me, with a very soft ask
- A newsletter built around impact stories
- A single impact story
- A fundraising email
That's four emails, and one of them is an appeal. The year before I came, the organization sent about four appeals in a whole year.
I don't think donors mind hearing from us. I think they mind hearing from us only when we want something. Here's how to use email to build a relationship with donors between gifts. For the rest of your program, see the guide to nonprofit email marketing.
Start with the welcome
A relationship by email begins the day someone gives or signs up. In M+R's 2026 Benchmarks, welcome series emails had a 1.6% click rate, against 0.59% for standard fundraising emails. People pay attention at the start.
When I built my first welcome series at Food for the Hungry, I automated one email and got it working before adding the next. One good welcome email is better than a five-part series you never finish. Here are nine emails you can add over time.
Write as a person
Most nonprofit email reads like it came from a department. Send yours from a named person, in the first person, with a signature.
One of our four emails each month is a president's letter from me. It reads like a letter, and the ask in it is very soft.
Tell them what their gift did
When I make small gifts to other organizations, what I usually get back is a receipt, and later an appeal. Very few tell me what happened.
Two of our four monthly emails at Serving Orphans Worldwide are built around stories of impact. A donor who reads those knows what their giving is doing before we ask again.
Finding the stories is the hard part. We ask every home we support for prayer requests and praise reports in a monthly report, and many of our stories begin there.
Invite a reply
Ask a question and mean it. "What made you start giving to us? Hit reply and tell me." Read every answer. Write back.
A reply tells you what a donor cares about, which is information you can't get any other way at that cost.
Ask in proportion
There's no single right number of asks. An international relief organization may ask more often than a local private school. Signs that you're asking too much:
- Unsubscribes are rising.
- Asks outnumber stories and reports.
- Donors stop giving through email.
When you do ask, be clear: one story, one amount, one deadline.
Don't assume the bigger organization does it better
At one point I admired a larger organization doing similar work and wondered whether our own digital efforts measured up. Then a colleague who was part of an interagency group told me that people on that organization's digital team were impressed by our email fundraising. We'd been looking up at them while they were noticing what we did well.
Learn from others. Then trust what your own donors respond to.
Check what arrives
At Food for the Hungry, I signed up for our own emails once a year as a new donor, to see what showed up. My team joked that every July I'd tell them something was broken. Sometimes the welcome series never came. Sometimes I emailed our contact address and nobody answered.
Looking back, I should have done it every quarter. An email relationship only works if the emails arrive.
Where to start this week
Write down every email you sent donors in the last 90 days and mark each as an ask, a story, a report or a thank-you. If asks are more than a third, plan next month with one ask and three others. Start with a short letter from your leader that asks for nothing.
Related
Questions fundraisers ask
How often should a nonprofit email its donors?
There's no universal number. It depends on your donors. At Serving Orphans Worldwide we send about four emails a month, and only one is a fundraising email. Watch unsubscribe rates and giving. If unsubscribes rise or donors stop giving through email, pull back.
What should I send besides appeals?
A letter from your leader, a story of one person helped, a short report on what gifts accomplished and an occasional question for donors to answer. These give donors a reason to open your emails when you aren't asking.
Should donors be able to reply to my emails?
Yes. Send from a real person's address and say you'd like to hear back. Then make sure someone reads and answers every reply within a day or two.
How do I know if email is building relationships?
Look at replies, at how many donors give a second time and at whether donors who read your emails give more over a year. Open rates alone won't tell you.
Ask a fundraiser




