Donor Relations

8 Best Practices for Using a Donor CRM

Eight best practices for getting more from your donor CRM: choosing well, data standards, clean data, automated thank-yous, workflows and useful reports.

A donor CRM (constituent relationship management system) is where your donor records, gifts, notes and history live. Used well, it helps you thank donors quickly, send the right message to the right people and see what's working. Used poorly, it becomes an expensive list nobody trusts.

The difference usually isn't the software. It's the habits around it. Here are eight best practices for getting more from your donor CRM, whichever system you use.

1. Choose for your process, not the feature list

If you're choosing or replacing a CRM, start by writing down how your fundraising actually works: how gifts come in, how you thank donors, who needs which reports, which tools must connect. Then look for a system that fits.

Ask each vendor:

  • Does it connect to our online giving forms, email platform and accounting system?
  • How are gifts entered, and how do online gifts flow in?
  • Can it automate thank-you emails and tasks?
  • What reports come standard, and how hard is it to build our own?
  • What does it cost in year one and year three, including training and add-ons?
  • Can we get our data out if we leave?

Be wary of buying more system than you'll use. A small team is often better served by a simpler CRM it uses fully than a powerful one it uses badly. Here's why software alone won't save your fundraising.

2. Set data entry standards and write them down

Most CRM problems start with inconsistent entry. One person types "Street," another "St." One records a gift as "Year-End," another as "December appeal." A year later, nobody can trust the reports.

Write a short data entry guide covering:

  • Names, addresses and salutations
  • How households and couples are recorded
  • How gifts are coded: fund, campaign, appeal and source
  • How to record soft credits, tributes and matching gifts
  • What notes to log after a call or visit, and where

Keep it to a few pages, train everyone who enters data and update it when something changes.

3. Make the CRM part of daily work

A CRM only knows what you tell it. If calls, visits and donor preferences live in someone's inbox or head, they leave when that person does.

Build the CRM into routines: log every meaningful conversation the same day, set the next step as a task, and check your task list each morning. For major and mid-level donors especially, the history in the CRM is what lets a new fundraiser pick up a relationship without starting over.

4. Automate the thank-you, then make it personal

The CRM should make sure no gift goes unthanked. Set up automatic receipts and thank-you emails for online gifts, and a daily list of gifts that need a call or handwritten note.

But a receipt isn't stewardship. When I make small gifts to organizations, it's common for the experience to end with a transactional receipt. Even large organizations that should know better sometimes send the receipt and then nothing meaningful afterward. Use automation to get the receipt out fast, and use the time it saves to make personal thank-yous possible: a call from a board member, a note from staff, a short video.

5. Keep your data clean

Bad data costs money. Returned mail, emails to old addresses and duplicate records that send two appeals to the same person all waste budget and annoy donors.

Make cleaning a routine, not a once-a-decade project:

  • Merge duplicates monthly.
  • Run your mailing list through the National Change of Address service before major mailings.
  • Update records when mail comes back or emails bounce.
  • Mark deceased donors promptly and carefully.
  • Record and honor preferences, like "no phone calls" or "one mailing a year."

6. Set up workflows for the moments that matter

Use the CRM to make sure important things happen every time, not just when someone remembers. Useful workflows include:

  • A welcome series for every new donor
  • Second-gift follow-up for first-time donors, since only about one in four gives again
  • Failed payment recovery for monthly donors

That last one matters more than most organizations realize. At Food for the Hungry and World Concern, both organizations had a process for child sponsors whose recurring payment failed because a card expired or the number changed. It ran about 60 days across several channels: an email with a link to update the card, then a phone call, then a letter, then a postcard. It stopped as soon as the sponsor updated the payment. Many sponsors responded to the first email.

7. Segment and personalize

Your CRM lets you treat donors differently based on what you know about them. At a minimum, separate:

  • First-time donors from repeat donors
  • Monthly donors from one-time donors
  • Mid-level and major donors from everyone else
  • Lapsed donors (LYBUNTs and SYBUNTs) from active ones

Then adjust what each group receives. A monthly donor shouldn't get the same appeal as someone who gave once three years ago. Here's more on donor segmentation.

8. Build the reports you'll actually use

Pick a handful of reports and run them on a schedule:

  • Gifts and revenue against plan, monthly
  • New, retained, lapsed and reactivated donors
  • First-time donor second-gift rate
  • Monthly donors added and lost
  • Results by appeal and channel
  • Major and mid-level portfolios by fundraiser

Keep channel reports and portfolio reports separate, so the team that found a donor and the team that cultivates them both get credit for their part. Here are 21 digital fundraising KPIs and nonprofit benchmark metrics to compare against.

Train everyone, and keep training

Every person who touches the CRM needs training when they start and a refresher when something changes. Name one person as the CRM owner: the go-to for questions, standards and fixes. Without an owner, small problems pile up until nobody trusts the data.

A CRM is a tool for relationships. If you'd like a simple system for thanking and staying in touch with donors all year, The Gratitude System walks you through it.

Questions fundraisers ask

What is a donor CRM?

A database that stores donor records, gifts, notes and history, and helps a nonprofit thank donors, segment them and report on results.

How do I choose a donor CRM?

Write down how your fundraising works first, then compare systems on how well they fit that process, connect to your other tools, report and cost over several years.

How often should you clean donor data?

Merge duplicates monthly, update addresses before major mailings and fix bounced emails and returned mail as they happen.

Who should own the donor CRM?

Name one person as the CRM owner to set standards, answer questions and fix problems, even if many people enter data.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedcrmfundraising

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside