Creating Urgency in Your Case for Support

Major Gifts, Intermediate

By Jeremy Reis

Urgency can make the difference between inspiring a potential donor to give now versus putting it off indefinitely. When you create urgency in your case for support, you help donors feel that their immediate involvement is essential.

Here’s how to strategically weave urgency into your case for support to make it compelling and action-oriented.

Define Urgency in the Context of Your Case for Support

What Urgency Means in Fundraising

Urgency in your case for support isn’t about a generic push for donations; it’s about conveying the immediate, critical nature of the needs your organization addresses. Use urgency to show that donor action—or inaction—will make an immediate difference. This heightened focus helps donors feel that acting now, rather than waiting, will directly impact the lives and situations at stake.

Types of Urgency That Work in a Case for Support

Identify specific types of urgency that make sense for your mission. Time-sensitive needs can stem from current events, escalating challenges, or one-time opportunities. For instance, focus on urgent issues like natural disasters, crises that demand a rapid response, or a unique opportunity for a matching grant. Each approach shows donors why their support matters now.

Why Urgency Works in a Case for Support

Adding urgency boosts the impact of your message by anchoring it in the present. When donors see that the situation is critical and that their support is needed immediately, they’re far more likely to respond. Urgency engages them not just with the mission but with the moment, showing that their involvement is needed right now to make a difference.

Highlight Time-Sensitive Issues

Tie your case for support to real-time events or crises to make your message timely. If your organization is providing relief for a natural disaster or urgent humanitarian need, emphasize this current situation in your case. Referencing real-time needs gives your appeal relevance and shows donors why support is needed today.

Feature Expiring Opportunities or Matching Gifts

Limited-time opportunities, like matching gifts or challenge grants, create built-in urgency. Explain how donors can double their impact if they give by a specific deadline. Use phrases like “Every dollar will be matched until the end of the month” to emphasize both the deadline and the enhanced impact of their gift, which drives donors to act quickly.

Emphasize Seasonal or Period-Specific Needs

Leverage specific times of the year when needs increase. Describe seasonal demands, such as the need for winter clothing or holiday meals. Year-end or back-to-school campaigns also create natural windows for urgency. Showing how time-limited needs fit into your mission can strengthen your case and encourage prompt donor action.

Illustrate Growing Needs and Escalating Problems

Use Data to Show the Scale and Growth of the Problem

Show donors how the problem is growing by sharing data that illustrates the escalating scale of the issue. For example, if food insecurity in your area has risen by 15% each year, include this statistic. Concrete data points demonstrate the urgency of the situation and make it clear that waiting to act could worsen the problem.

Explain the Consequences of Inaction

Describe what could happen if your organization doesn’t get immediate support. Explain the compounding effects of inaction. For instance, “Every day without clean water, more children face health risks.” By laying out the real-world impact of delaying support, you show donors that taking action now is essential.

Highlight Progress at Risk Without Sustained Support

If your organization has achieved recent success, emphasize that continued progress depends on donor support. Show that without action, prior gains could be lost. By framing their support as essential to maintaining progress, you reinforce the urgency of continued involvement.

Make Urgency Personal with Stories and Testimonials

Tell Stories of Individuals Facing Immediate Needs

Make the urgency real by focusing on specific individuals or families who need support right now. For example, “Maria, a single mother, is one of thousands facing a harsh winter without adequate shelter.” Personalizing the need gives donors a face to connect with and reinforces the immediate impact they can have.

Include Testimonials from Beneficiaries

Use direct quotes from people impacted by your work to drive home the urgency. Share testimonials from beneficiaries who express their gratitude for the support received or their immediate need for more help. These voices add authenticity and make the case for urgency even stronger.

Appeal Directly from Program Leaders

Use the perspective of those on the ground to emphasize the immediacy of the need. Include quotes from program managers or field leaders who witness the situation firsthand. For example, “Our team urgently needs more resources to keep up with growing demand.” A direct appeal from a trusted leader shows the frontline urgency and brings credibility to your message.

Use Compelling Language to Create Emotional Urgency

Choose Active, Immediate Language

Use language that reinforces urgency throughout your case. Words like “now,” “immediately,” “urgent,” and “today” create an active tone that draws donors in. Phrases like “Act now to make a difference” and “Your support is urgently needed today” inspire a sense of immediacy.

Invoke FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)

Show donors they have a unique opportunity to make a difference that might not be available later. For example, “Join others who are stepping up today to bring relief.” This kind of message appeals to donors’ desire to be part of something impactful, inspiring them to act sooner.

Outline the Consequences of Inaction

Remind donors what’s at stake if they don’t take action. “Without immediate support, many families will go without food this winter.” Conveying the potential loss associated with delayed support adds weight to your appeal, motivating donors to act quickly.

Build Urgency into Your Call to Action

Use Specific Timeframes for Action

In your call to action, add a clear timeframe. Use language like “Help within the next 30 days to ensure no one is turned away.” A defined timeframe strengthens the urgency and gives donors a clear deadline, making it more likely they’ll take immediate action.

Include Limited-Time Matches or Challenges

If a matching gift or challenge grant is available, feature it prominently. Explain that “All gifts made by [date] will be doubled,” so donors understand both the time limit and the increased impact of their support. Specific matching deadlines add urgency and make the call to action feel more pressing.

Position Recurring Giving as a Solution to Ongoing Urgent Needs

Urgency isn’t only for one-time gifts. Position recurring giving as a way for donors to address ongoing, urgent needs. For example, “A monthly gift ensures continuous support for families facing immediate hardships.” This approach reinforces the idea that continuous support is just as critical as immediate action.

Use Visuals and Design to Emphasize Urgency

Incorporate Timelines and Countdown Graphics

Visual elements like timelines or countdowns reinforce urgency. For example, a graphic that says “Only 5 days left” creates a visible deadline that encourages donors to act quickly. Timelines can show the narrow window remaining to meet a goal, making the urgency tangible.

Highlight Key Phrases and Data

Use bold text, color, or different fonts to make urgent messages stand out. Highlighting phrases like “immediate need” or “act now” visually reinforces urgency, ensuring that these parts of your message catch the donor’s eye.

Use Emotionally Impactful Imagery

Include powerful images that illustrate the immediate need. Photos of affected communities or individuals in need of support help create an emotional connection, underscoring the urgency. Use recent photos that show the situation clearly, adding visual weight to your case for support.

Adding urgency to your case for support transforms it from a general appeal into a time-sensitive, powerful call to action. By defining your needs as critical, showing growing challenges, including personal stories, and using a clear deadline, you can motivate donors to contribute right when their support matters most. Review your case for support, add layers of urgency where appropriate, and watch your message drive immediate, meaningful donor engagement for your nonprofit’s mission.