Email Marketing

How to Write a Call to Action for a Fundraising Email

The call to action is where a reader becomes a donor, or doesn't. Here's how to write one that's clear, where to put it, and what to check on the page it leads to.

At Food for the Hungry, we used mouse-tracking software to watch how people moved through our child sponsorship website. We saw something we hadn't expected. Many visitors clicked "Sponsor a Child" in the header, found a child they wanted to sponsor and then clicked that same header button again.

The real button for sponsoring the child they'd chosen was farther down the page, and it was hard to recognize. People who had already decided couldn't find the way to do it. We redesigned the button.

That's what a call to action is for. It's the place where a reader who has decided to help finds out how. Here's how to write one for a fundraising email. For the rest of your program, see the guide to nonprofit email marketing.

One action

Decide the one thing you want the reader to do, and ask for only that. If the email is an appeal, the action is to give. Leave the volunteer sign-up and the social media links for another day.

Then repeat it. A sentence with a link after the story, a button, and the ask again at the end or in a P.S.

Say what the gift does

Compare:

  • "Donate now"
  • "Give a week of groceries"

Both lead to the same page. The second tells the reader what they're doing.

A good ask sentence has an amount, a result and a date: "Will you give $50 by Friday to stock a family's kitchen for a week?" The button under it can repeat the result in a few words.

Use the first person on buttons if you like. "Double my gift" reads as the donor's own choice.

Make it easy to find and to tap

  • Use a button in a color that contrasts with the rest of the email.
  • Make it large enough for a thumb. Many of your readers are on a phone.
  • Put space around it so it isn't crowded by other links.
  • Link the photo and one sentence as well. People click different things.
  • Include a text link in case images don't load.

Give a reason to act today

A call to action with no reason to act now gets set aside. A deadline or a match gives it one. One year at World Concern, the first email in our year-end campaign fell flat. We added a small matching gift to the next email, and the response was much better.

Put the reason in the sentence beside the button: "Every gift is matched until midnight Friday."

Check where it leads

The call to action doesn't end at the click. The page it opens has to continue the same message.

At Food for the Hungry, we noticed visitors often went from our financials page to the donation page, so we added a call to action at the bottom of the financials page to make that step easier.

I once helped a friend's nonprofit test a single long donation form against a two-step checkout. I expected the single page to win. The two-step version got 15% more conversions and a higher average gift.

Before you send, click your own button on a phone. Does the page mention the same story and the same amount? Is the form short? Can you finish in a minute?

Test it

Test one thing at a time:

  • The words on the button
  • The amount in the ask
  • A button against a text link
  • Where the first ask appears

Send each version to part of your list and compare gifts, not only clicks.

Common mistakes

  • Several different asks in one email
  • "Click here" with no hint of what happens next
  • A button below a long email that few readers reach
  • A link to your homepage in place of the donation page
  • No deadline
  • A page that doesn't work on a phone

Where to start this week

Open your last fundraising email on your phone. Count the different things it asks the reader to do. If it's more than one, cut the rest. Then tap the button and try to give $10. Fix the first thing that slows you down.

Questions fundraisers ask

What is a call to action in a fundraising email?

The part of the email that asks the reader to do something and gives them a way to do it, usually a sentence with an ask followed by a link or a button to a donation page.

How many calls to action should an email have?

One action, repeated two or three times. An email that asks readers to give, volunteer, follow and share gets fewer of each than an email that asks for one thing.

What should a donate button say?

Something specific to the appeal, such as "Give a week of groceries" or "Double my gift." Plain "Donate" works, but it tells the reader nothing about what happens next.

Where should the call to action go?

After the story's turn, near the top, and again at the end. Readers who skim should be able to find it without scrolling far.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedcall to actionctaemailemail appeallink

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside