The Art of the Call-to-Action in Email Fundraising

, Fundraising, Intermediate

By Jeremy Reis

There’s one tool that, when wielded with precision, has the potential to mobilize supporters like no other: the email. It’s easy to overlook, given the array of flashy digital platforms and strategies available to us today. But email remains a cornerstone of donor communication — direct, personal, and surprisingly resilient in an age of fleeting online interactions.

Now, while the medium of email is powerful, its true potential is unlocked only when it contains a compelling call-to-action (CTA). Think of your email as a conversation with a friend over coffee. You can recount the most heart-wrenching stories or share the most urgent needs, but if, by the end of your tale, you haven’t clearly articulated what you’d like your friend to do, the moment passes. They’re moved, but motionless. That’s the essence of the CTA – it’s your guiding hand, steering the willing hearts of your supporters towards tangible action.

Fundraisers, it’s high time we grasp this simple truth: an email without an effective CTA is like a ship without a rudder. Sure, it might float, but it won’t necessarily go where you want it to. A finely-crafted CTA, on the other hand, has the potential to not only inspire immediate action but also to pave the way for lasting donor relationships.

Table of Contents

What is the Call-to-Action?

Fundraisers, brace yourselves for an often overlooked but undeniably potent truth: It’s not just what you say, but how you invite action that can determine the success of your email campaign. I’m talking about the under appreciated hero of digital fundraising – the Call-to-Action (CTA).

At its core, a CTA is a clear and compelling invitation for your reader to take a specific step. It’s the bridge between passive reading and active participation. Whether you want them to donate, sign up for an event, or simply learn more, your CTA is the flashing neon sign that says, “This way to make a difference!”

Let’s take a real-world dive into the power of CTAs:

Example 1: Two similar organizations, both working to provide clean water in underserved communities, sent out email appeals. One ended with, “Help us in our mission.” The other was more direct: “Donate now to provide a family with clean water for a month.” Can you guess which one had a higher click-through rate? The second, by a significant margin. Why? It gave a clear, tangible action for the reader to take, illuminating the immediate impact of their contribution.

Example 2: An animal rescue charity had always ended their emails with the generic “Support Us Today.” However, after tweaking their CTA to: “Click here to feed a shelter pet for a week,” their engagement soared. The change showcased a direct outcome, offering donors a clear picture of the difference their support would make.

These examples underscore a fundamental tenet: specificity and clarity drive action. Your donors want to know their contributions – whether time, money, or resources – have a palpable impact. Your CTA is your opportunity to illustrate just that.

But beyond its directive nature, a CTA serves another pivotal function. It becomes a beacon of possibility, a testament to the idea that individual actions, when aggregated, can usher transformative change. Every time a supporter heeds your call, they’re not just performing a task; they’re joining a movement, they’re becoming part of a story, and they’re shaping the narrative of change.

In nonprofit fundraising, where the competition for attention and resources is fierce, understanding and harnessing the power of the CTA can set you apart. It’s not merely about asking; it’s about inspiring, guiding, and providing a clear path for your supporters to walk beside you in your mission.

Crafting a Compelling CTA

When you’re on the front lines of nonprofit fundraising and email strategy, every word counts. And in the world of email outreach, there’s nothing more pivotal than the Call-to-Action (CTA). But how do you craft one that not only grabs attention but also spurs action? Let’s dive in.

a. Emotional Resonance

Using stories to create a connection:
Think back to a story that touched your heartstrings. Maybe it was about a single mom overcoming adversity or a community rallying around a cause. These narratives don’t just inform; they connect, they inspire. And when your CTA is rooted in a genuine, heartfelt story, it moves beyond being just a directive—it becomes an invitation to be part of a larger tale. You can use video in emails to generate more interest.

Why donors give: the emotional triggers:
People rarely give because of dry statistics. They give because they feel. They give because they relate, empathize, and envision a better world. Understanding this human tendency towards emotion-driven actions can help you frame your CTA in a way that tugs at the heart.

b. Clarity is King

Avoiding jargon and industry terms:
Remember, many of your readers aren’t industry insiders. Terms that seem everyday to you might sound alien to them. Be conscious of this. Instead of saying “Help us reach our Q3 objectives,” perhaps go with “Help us bring clean water to 300 families this month.”

Making your ask specific and tangible:
Vagueness can be the enemy of action. Instead of asking donors to “support your cause,” direct them with “Donate $20 to provide school supplies for a child for a year.” When donors can visualize the impact of their contribution, they’re more likely to act.

c. The Urgency Factor

Why “now” is the best time to donate:
Human nature often leans towards procrastination. But when we understand that a need is immediate, we’re more likely to act swiftly. Position your CTA in a manner that emphasizes the present moment. Maybe there’s a matching grant that doubles donations made today, or perhaps a recent event has heightened the urgency of your mission.

Creating a sense of timely necessity without appearing pushy:
There’s a fine line between emphasizing urgency and sounding desperate or pushy. It’s not about creating panic; it’s about illuminating importance. Phrases like “Join us in making a difference today” or “Your timely contribution can change lives now” strike the balance between urgency and genuine need.

A successful CTA is a blend of heart, clarity, and timeliness. As you craft yours, always remember the power it holds—to inspire, to mobilize, and to effect change one click at a time.

Visual Elements and Design

In the orchestra of email fundraising, while your content is the melody, visual design is the rhythm guiding your reader’s journey. It’s not just about what you’re saying; it’s also about how you’re visually presenting that message. Let’s unravel the art of visual cues and designs that make your CTAs pop and prompt action.

Importance of Visual Cues in Guiding Reader Action

Imagine landing on an email full of text with no breaks, no images, and no discernible sections. Overwhelming, right? Visual cues break the monotony, guide readers through the content, and subtly steer them towards the desired action. Elements like arrows pointing to the CTA, contrasting colors, or even whitespace around the action button can create a focus, making it easier for the reader to navigate and understand where to click.

Button Design: Size, Color, and Placement

Size: A CTA button should be large enough to be noticed but not so large that it’s obtrusive. It’s about balance. If a donor has to squint to find your button or feels visually shouted at, you’ve missed the mark.

Color: Colors evoke emotions. A red might communicate urgency, while a blue could convey trust. Using a color that contrasts with the rest of your email can make the button stand out. But remember, consistency is key. If a particular color represents your organization, use it to your advantage.

Placement: Ideally, the primary CTA should be placed above the fold, ensuring it’s visible without scrolling. However, for longer emails, consider adding it again at the end. This way, after engaging with your content, readers have a clear action step waiting for them.

Mobile Optimization: Ensuring CTAs are Clear and Clickable on All Devices

The world is mobile, and so are your donors. A beautifully designed email CTA on desktop might turn into a tiny, unclickable speck on a smartphone. Ensuring your CTAs are mobile-optimized is no longer optional—it’s imperative. Here’s the deal:

  1. Thumb-friendly design: Make buttons large enough for mobile users to tap without zooming.
  2. Clarity over clutter: On smaller screens, less is more. Keep design elements simple and clear.
  3. Test and test again: Before sending out that email, test it on different devices. Ensure your CTA is as clear and clickable on a tiny smartphone screen as it is on a large desktop monitor.

Remember, your CTA is the culmination of your email’s purpose. It’s the crescendo in your symphony. And in this visual age, how you present that CTA—through design and visual cues—can significantly amplify its impact. Don’t just tell your donors what to do; show them, guide them, and make their journey seamless and intuitive.

Testing and Iteration: No CTA is Perfect

There’s a golden thread we often overlook in email fundraising: the notion that perfection is a journey, not a destination. Every Call-to-Action (CTA) you craft, no matter how stellar, has room for improvement. Let’s venture into the world of testing, iterating, and continually refining those CTAs to resonate deeper and drive more profound action.

A/B Testing Your Emails to Understand What Resonates

A/B testing, or split testing, is the fundraiser’s crystal ball. Imagine sending two slightly varied versions of an email to two segments of your audience. One has a green “Donate Now” button; the other a blue “Support Us Today” button. Which one garners more clicks? A/B testing gives you those insights.

The beauty of this approach? It’s not about guessing; it’s about knowing. By continuously testing variations of your CTAs—be it color, wording, placement, or size—you get data-backed insights on what truly resonates with your audience.

Iterating Based on Results: The Cycle of Improvement

Testing alone isn’t the magic wand; acting on those test results is. Once you discern what’s working (and what’s not), iterate. If “Help a Child Today” garners more engagement than “Support Our Cause,” it’s a clear signal to lean into more personalized, urgent phrasing.

Remember, iteration is a cycle. As your audience grows and evolves, their preferences might too. Being wedded to a static approach can be detrimental. Keep testing, keep refining, and let your CTAs evolve in tandem with your audience’s pulse. And when you keep testing, you’ll find the ability to grow your email fundraising

Case Studies: CTAs that Evolved Over Time and Their Success Rates

Sheltered Paws: This animal rescue charity started with a simple “Donate Today.” After multiple rounds of A/B testing and iterations, they landed on “Feed a Sheltered Pup for a Week.” The result? A whopping 47% increase in click-through rates.

Books for All: Initially using “Give the Gift of Reading,” they tested a more tangible CTA: “Gift a Book Kit to a Classroom.” Not only did they see a 35% rise in donations, but the feedback revealed donors felt more connected, knowing the specific impact of their contribution.

These case studies illuminate a singular truth: CTAs aren’t a ‘set and forget’ element. They’re living, breathing entities that can (and should) morph based on audience response.

The success of your CTAs lies not just in their creation but in their continuous evolution. So, fundraisers, wear the hat of a scientist. Experiment, analyze, refine, and let every CTA be better than the last. The journey to perfection is endless, but every step brings you closer.

Common Mistakes and Pitfalls to Avoid

None of us are immune to making mistakes with our CTAs. Let’s discuss a few ways we might mess up a CTA and how to correct it.

Being Too Vague or General

The allure of broadness is tempting; casting a wide net feels safe. But “Support Us” or “Help Our Cause” might leave donors scratching their heads. What does support look like? How, specifically, can they help?

A compelling CTA is precise and actionable. It tells donors exactly what step to take next. Instead of “Join Our Mission,” how about “Provide a Meal for a Family in Need”? The latter doesn’t just ask for help—it paints a vivid picture of impact.

Overloading Your Email with Multiple CTAs

Imagine being at a crossroads with ten different paths and no clear signposts. Overwhelming, isn’t it? The same principle applies to your email. Bombarding readers with “Donate Now,” “Join Our Webinar,” “Follow Us on Social Media,” and “Volunteer This Weekend” all in one go can create decision paralysis.

When you offer too many choices, you risk diluting the message and causing inaction. Prioritize. What is the single most important action you want readers to take? Highlight that. If you must include secondary actions, ensure they’re visually less dominant, allowing the primary CTA to shine.

Neglecting the Mobile Experience

In today’s digital age, neglecting mobile is akin to forgetting a significant chunk of your audience. A beautiful, well-crafted CTA on a desktop might transform into a cryptic, unclickable enigma on a smartphone.

A few cardinal rules for mobile:

  1. Thumb-friendly design: Ensure buttons are adequately sized for easy tapping.
  2. Visibility: Mobile screens are compact. Your CTA should be prominent, ensuring it doesn’t get lost in the email’s sea of content.
  3. Test: Before hitting send, view the email on different devices. Ensure that the experience remains consistent and that your CTA is still as compelling and clickable.

The art of crafting the perfect CTA is indeed that—an art, combined with a dash of science. And as with any art form, pitfalls are part and parcel of the process. But by being aware, you can steer clear of these common mistakes, letting your CTAs shine and truly resonate with your audience. Remember, the aim is not just to be seen, but to inspire action. Aim for clarity, simplicity, and focus, and let every CTA be a step closer to your mission’s success.

Remember, while the guidelines outlined here serve as a roadmap, the journey to the ultimate Call-to-Action is one of continuous learning and adaptation. It’s about understanding your donors, embracing feedback, and most crucially, being willing to iterate.

More resources:


Get Your Free Course!