Donor Communication
The Art of the Follow-Up: How to Keep Donors Informed and Engaged
Most donors hear from a nonprofit once after they give: a receipt. Here's how to follow up so donors know what their gift did and are glad to give again.

When I make small gifts to organizations, the experience usually ends with a receipt. That's true even at large organizations that should know better. I may land on an appeal list later. Hearing someone say thank you personally is surprisingly rare.
That silence is part of the donor's experience. What you do after a gift decides whether there's a second one. In Virtuous's 2026 benchmark report, only 25.8% of first-time donors made a second gift.
Here's how to follow up well. For the full picture, see 10 tips to improve donor retention.
What follow-up is for
Good follow-up does three things:
- Informs. The donor learns what their gift did.
- Engages. The donor feels known and valued.
- Prepares. The donor is ready to hear the next request.
Inform: tell donors what happened
Donors give to make something happen. Tell them it did.
- Thank them quickly. A receipt right away and a personal thank-you within two days.
- Report back. "Your gift helped 40 children start school with supplies." Be specific.
- Tell one story. One person, one change.
- Be honest when plans change. If a project is delayed, say so.
Find out what the donor is trying to accomplish, and report on that. A donor who gives so children can go to school wants to hear about children in school.
Engage: make it personal
- Use their name and their history. "You've given every spring for six years."
- Write by hand. A handwritten card stands out because so few arrive.
- Call. A two-minute call to say thank you, with no ask.
- Ask a question. "What led you to give?" Then record the answer.
- Invite them in. A tour, a volunteer day or a short video from the field.
When I joined World Concern, the second-year renewal rate for new donors was about 6%. We added phone calls to new donors, welcome letters and welcome kits for monthly donors. By the end of the first year, it had risen to 22%. By the time I left, it was closer to 30%.
Prepare: get ready for the next ask
A donor who has been thanked and has heard what their gift did is ready to be asked again.
- Report before you ask. Don't let the next appeal be the first thing they hear.
- Connect the next need to the last gift. "Because of you, 40 children started school. Twelve more are waiting."
- Offer a next step that fits: a second gift, monthly giving or a larger project.
- Watch the timing. In Virtuous's data, the typical second gift comes about three and a half months after the first.
A simple schedule for a new donor
- Day 0: Automatic receipt
- Days 1 to 2: Personal thank-you by call, note or email
- Week 2: A story of what gifts like theirs do
- Month 1: A report on the specific project
- Month 2 or 3: A second ask, tied to the first gift
- Ongoing: Newsletter, updates and appeals in balance
Mistakes to avoid
- Only a receipt. A receipt is a record. It isn't a thank-you.
- Asking again too soon, before any report
- Generic messages with nothing about this donor
- Going silent between appeals
- Assuming it works. Systems break quietly.
On that last one: at Food for the Hungry, my team joked that every July they'd get a note from me saying something was broken. At least once a year I'd sign up, make a small gift and email the contact address to see what happened. Sometimes I never received the welcome series. Sometimes no one answered my email. The team would trace it and fix it.
Where to start this week
Make a small gift to your own organization using a personal email address. Write down everything you receive over the next 30 days and when. Then fix the first gap you find.
For more on trust, see 6 steps to build trust with your donors.
Questions fundraisers ask
How soon should I follow up after a donation?
Send a receipt immediately and a personal thank-you within two days. A report on what the gift accomplished should follow within the first month or two.
What should a donor follow-up include?
A sincere thank-you, a specific account of what the gift did, a story or photo and, later, an invitation to stay involved. Keep the first follow-up free of any new ask.
How often should I contact donors between asks?
It depends on your donors. A good rule is that donors should hear what their giving did at least as often as they're asked to give.
How do I follow up with donors if I have a small staff?
Automate the receipt and a welcome email. Then set aside an hour a week for handwritten notes and phone calls to new donors and your most loyal ones.
Ask a fundraiser




