Donor Communication

The Art of the Follow-Up: How to Keep Donors Informed and Engaged

Most donors hear from a nonprofit once after they give: a receipt. Here's how to follow up so donors know what their gift did and are glad to give again.

When I make small gifts to organizations, the experience usually ends with a receipt. That's true even at large organizations that should know better. I may land on an appeal list later. Hearing someone say thank you personally is surprisingly rare.

That silence is part of the donor's experience. What you do after a gift decides whether there's a second one. In Virtuous's 2026 benchmark report, only 25.8% of first-time donors made a second gift.

Here's how to follow up well. For the full picture, see 10 tips to improve donor retention.

What follow-up is for

Good follow-up does three things:

  • Informs. The donor learns what their gift did.
  • Engages. The donor feels known and valued.
  • Prepares. The donor is ready to hear the next request.

Inform: tell donors what happened

Donors give to make something happen. Tell them it did.

  • Thank them quickly. A receipt right away and a personal thank-you within two days.
  • Report back. "Your gift helped 40 children start school with supplies." Be specific.
  • Tell one story. One person, one change.
  • Be honest when plans change. If a project is delayed, say so.

Find out what the donor is trying to accomplish, and report on that. A donor who gives so children can go to school wants to hear about children in school.

Engage: make it personal

  • Use their name and their history. "You've given every spring for six years."
  • Write by hand. A handwritten card stands out because so few arrive.
  • Call. A two-minute call to say thank you, with no ask.
  • Ask a question. "What led you to give?" Then record the answer.
  • Invite them in. A tour, a volunteer day or a short video from the field.

When I joined World Concern, the second-year renewal rate for new donors was about 6%. We added phone calls to new donors, welcome letters and welcome kits for monthly donors. By the end of the first year, it had risen to 22%. By the time I left, it was closer to 30%.

Prepare: get ready for the next ask

A donor who has been thanked and has heard what their gift did is ready to be asked again.

  • Report before you ask. Don't let the next appeal be the first thing they hear.
  • Connect the next need to the last gift. "Because of you, 40 children started school. Twelve more are waiting."
  • Offer a next step that fits: a second gift, monthly giving or a larger project.
  • Watch the timing. In Virtuous's data, the typical second gift comes about three and a half months after the first.

A simple schedule for a new donor

  • Day 0: Automatic receipt
  • Days 1 to 2: Personal thank-you by call, note or email
  • Week 2: A story of what gifts like theirs do
  • Month 1: A report on the specific project
  • Month 2 or 3: A second ask, tied to the first gift
  • Ongoing: Newsletter, updates and appeals in balance

Mistakes to avoid

  • Only a receipt. A receipt is a record. It isn't a thank-you.
  • Asking again too soon, before any report
  • Generic messages with nothing about this donor
  • Going silent between appeals
  • Assuming it works. Systems break quietly.

On that last one: at Food for the Hungry, my team joked that every July they'd get a note from me saying something was broken. At least once a year I'd sign up, make a small gift and email the contact address to see what happened. Sometimes I never received the welcome series. Sometimes no one answered my email. The team would trace it and fix it.

Where to start this week

Make a small gift to your own organization using a personal email address. Write down everything you receive over the next 30 days and when. Then fix the first gap you find.

For more on trust, see 6 steps to build trust with your donors.

Questions fundraisers ask

How soon should I follow up after a donation?

Send a receipt immediately and a personal thank-you within two days. A report on what the gift accomplished should follow within the first month or two.

What should a donor follow-up include?

A sincere thank-you, a specific account of what the gift did, a story or photo and, later, an invitation to stay involved. Keep the first follow-up free of any new ask.

How often should I contact donors between asks?

It depends on your donors. A good rule is that donors should hear what their giving did at least as often as they're asked to give.

How do I follow up with donors if I have a small staff?

Automate the receipt and a welcome email. Then set aside an hour a week for handwritten notes and phone calls to new donors and your most loyal ones.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggeddonor relationsfollow upfundraisinggratituderetention

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside