Major Gifts

What Donors Think When You Ask (It's Not What You Fear)

Fundraisers often assume donors dread being asked. My experience says otherwise. Here's what I've seen donors do when asked, what they do dislike, and how that should change your approach.

Early in my career, I asked a donor for a gift and then kept talking, when I should have stopped to let him answer.

He was a kind older gentleman, and he stopped me. "Jeremy, Jeremy, stop talking. I'll give you the amount you need."

He had already decided. Everything I was afraid of was happening in my head and not in his.

Many fundraisers assume donors dread being asked. We picture them wincing at our name on the phone. I've carried that assumption myself, and my experience keeps contradicting it. Here's what I've seen. For more on how donors decide, see donor psychology: why people give and how to ask well.

The assumption we carry

We don't like asking, so we assume donors don't like being asked. That belief makes us delay, hedge and apologize. Sometimes it keeps us from asking at all.

On an early field trip, I spent a week with a couple and never made a direct ask. A staff member kept asking when I would. I kept saying, "Give me time." I was afraid, and they gave less than I'd hoped.

What I've seen donors do

They've often decided already. The gentleman who told me to stop talking wasn't weighing my arguments. He'd made up his mind.

They tell you when. A donor who says "come back after the new year" is telling you how to succeed.

They have goals of their own. Many donors are trying to accomplish something specific with their giving, and your organization is one of the ways they pursue it. Ask what it is.

They come back. A lapsed donor has already said yes to you once. A personal note with no ask is a good way to reopen the door.

Giving leads to more giving. At one church my family attended, the pastor worried that a year-end campaign would mean a slow January. We ran it anyway and raised more than our goal. That January was the highest-giving January the church had ever had. My own observation is that generosity begets generosity.

There's research in the same direction. In a 2008 study published in Science, Elizabeth Dunn, Lara Aknin and Michael Norton found that people who spent money on others reported greater happiness than those who spent it on themselves.

What donors do dislike

Donors have real frustrations. In my experience they're rarely about being asked.

Silence after the gift. I see this as a donor. When I make a small gift, the experience often ends with a receipt, and the next thing I get is an appeal.

Not getting a straight answer. A donor once wanted his $1,000 gift traced to a specific well with his name on it. We couldn't do that. The emails got unpleasant until I called and explained how our clean water fund worked. Once he understood, we recovered the gift. He needed a clear answer.

Starting over. When a staff member leaves and nothing is written down, the donor has to explain themselves again to someone new.

Being shown the wrong thing. On that field trip, I hadn't found out what the couple cared about. Nothing I showed them connected.

Look at that list. None of it is "being asked."

How this changes your approach

  • Ask clearly. Name the project and the amount.
  • Stop talking after you ask.
  • Don't apologize. See 7 phrases that sabotage your fundraising.
  • Learn what the donor cares about first.
  • Treat a no as information. Ask whether it's the project, the amount or the timing.
  • Put as much effort into the thank-you and the report as into the ask.

The invitation they may be waiting for

Some of your donors have been giving the same amount for years because nobody has shown them an opportunity to do more. Some people close to your organization have never given because nobody asked.

I can't promise every one of them will say yes. I can tell you that in my experience, the ask is seldom what damages a relationship. Neglect does that.

The assignment

Choose one donor you've been putting off asking. Write down what you're afraid will happen. Then call to set a meeting, tell them you'd like to share an idea for a gift and see what they say. Compare it with what you wrote.

For the conversation itself, see how to ask for money.

Questions fundraisers ask

Do donors mind being asked for money?

Most don't, when the ask is clear, fits what they care about and comes from someone who has thanked them and reported back. What bothers donors is being asked again without ever hearing what the last gift did.

Will asking too often make donors stop giving?

It can, if asks are all they hear. Watch for rising unsubscribes and donors who stop their usual giving. But a well-run ask doesn't use up generosity. At one church, a year-end campaign I helped with was followed by the church's highest-giving January ever.

What do donors dislike most about fundraising?

Silence after they give, being treated as a number, not getting a straight answer to a question and having to re-explain themselves every time staff change.

How should this change the way I ask?

Ask clearly and without apology, then be quiet. Find out what the donor cares about first. And put as much work into the thank-you and the report as into the ask.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggeddonor meetings

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside