Appeals are every model's weakest category
The best appeal score was 76.9, from GPT-6.2 Astra. Appeals carry 18% of the total, more than any other category, and all 18 models scored lower there than anywhere else.
We put 18 AI models through 38 tasks your development team handles every week: appeals, donor reports, grant proposals, major gift strategy. We judged each appeal against a control letter that has already proven it raises money. Everything else was graded with expert rubrics and answer keys. Then a working fundraiser checked every score.
Last update: November 21, 2026
The best appeal score was 76.9, from GPT-6.2 Astra. Appeals carry 18% of the total, more than any other category, and all 18 models scored lower there than anywhere else.
The top models scored in the mid 90s on reporting, testing and optimization, prospect research and ethics. GPT-6.2 Astra's 97.6 on testing was the highest single score.
Claude Haiku 5.5 scored 84.5 on storytelling but 65.9 on donor data analysis. If your team runs reports through AI, the model size matters.
Rank by the weighted overall score, or pick one category to see who is best at the work your team does most.
Showing 18 of 18 models · Each score combines three graded runs per test · Kit v3.1
Every model's score in all 14 categories. The percentage under each code is that category's share of the overall score.
We tested real fundraising tasks in ways AI can execute them.
A fictional secular relief and development nonprofit based in Denver, built so no model has seen it before.
Appeals, major gifts, donor data, grants, planned giving, stewardship and more. Each prompt is written the way a senior fundraiser briefs a capable colleague.
Every model runs every test three times, 114 graded runs in all, so one lucky answer cannot carry a score.
Appeals are judged by six graders against a control appeal. Rubric tests take the median of three graders. Data tests are checked against an answer key. A human confirms every score.
A new fact, figure, name or quote with no basis in the source material is an automatic zero for that run.
Appeals count most, at 18%, because they're the most widely used and move the most money from everyday donors.