Leadership

How to Set a Fundraising Goal Your Budget Didn't Make Up

Most fundraising goals are just the hole left in the budget. Build yours from the bottom up, starting with the donors you already have, then have an honest conversation about the gap.

Most nonprofit fundraising goals are set backward. The finance committee adds up next year's expenses, subtracts earned revenue and grants already in hand, and whatever is left becomes "the fundraising goal." Nobody asks whether the donor file can produce that number. It's simply the hole that needs filling.

That approach tells you what you need. It doesn't tell you what you're likely to raise. When those two numbers are far apart and nobody knows it until October, the year-end appeal ends up carrying far more weight than it can bear, and the board finds out in December.

There's a better way to set a fundraising goal, and it doesn't require software or a consultant. You build the number from the bottom up, starting with the donors you already have. Then you put it next to the budget number and have an honest conversation about the difference.

Start with the people, not the percentage

A bottom-up goal asks a simple question for each source of revenue: who, specifically, is going to give, and how much is reasonable to expect from them?

That means breaking your revenue into pieces you can actually reason about:

  • Retained donors. How many of last year's donors will give again, multiplied by what they typically give.
  • Upgrades. The extra amount you expect from donors you plan to ask for more. Only the increase counts here, so you don't double count.
  • Reactivated lapsed donors. Former donors who come back.
  • New donors. Based on what your acquisition efforts have actually produced, not what you hope they'll produce.
  • Major gifts, by name. Every donor or prospect listed individually, with an ask amount and an honest probability.
  • Grants, by status. Awarded, pending renewal, submitted, and not yet written are four very different things.

The retention rates you plug in should be your own. If you don't know them, the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's full-year 2025 report is a reasonable sanity check: overall donor retention was 43.3%, first-year donor retention was 18.9%, and repeat donor retention was 59.3%. The recapture rate for lapsed donors was just 3.0%. In plain terms, roughly four out of five of last year's first-time donors probably won't give this year unless something changes.

The same report found that donor counts fell an estimated 3.6% in 2025 while dollars grew 5.0%. Fewer donors are giving more money overall. If your budget assumes growth from a bigger donor base, that assumption deserves a second look.

A worked example: a county animal shelter

Imagine a hypothetical animal shelter with a $1.3 million budget. Adoption fees and a county contract cover part of it. The board-approved budget needs $540,000 in contributed revenue, about 16% more than the $465,500 the shelter raised last year. Nobody has checked that number against the donor file.

Here's what the file looks like. Last year, 900 repeat donors gave an average of $230 each, and 450 first-time donors gave an average of $90. (The shelter's nine major donors are counted separately.) The shelter's own history shows about 70% of repeat donors and 30% of first-year donors give again, and that retained first-year donors average about $120 in their second year. Both rates are better than the sector benchmarks above, which is why using your own data matters. Over the last three years, the shelter has averaged 500 new donors a year at about $90 each. There are 2,000 lapsed donors on file.

The development director builds the goal line by line:

Source

How it's calculated

Projected

Retained repeat donors

900 × 70% = 630 donors × $230

$144,900

Retained first-year donors

450 × 30% = 135 donors × $120

$16,200

Upgrades (increase only)

120 donors asked × 25% = 30 donors × $150 more

$4,500

Reactivated lapsed donors

2,000 × 3% = 60 donors × $90

$5,400

New donors

500 donors × $90

$45,000

Individual giving subtotal

$216,000

Major gift renewals (9 names)

$78,000 given last year × 85%

$66,300

Major gift upgrade asks (3 names)

$15,000 in added asks × 40%

$6,000

New major prospects (5 names, all met in person)

$50,000 in asks × 20%

$10,000

Major gifts subtotal

$82,300

Grants awarded or committed

$60,000 × 100%

$60,000

Grant renewals pending

$95,000 × 70%

$66,500

New applications submitted

$80,000 × 25%

$20,000

Prospects researched, not yet applied

$50,000 × 10%

$5,000

Grants subtotal

$151,500

Bottom-up total

$449,800

The budget needs $540,000. The donor file supports about $449,800. That's a $90,200 gap, and the bottom-up number is actually a little below last year's $465,500.

That last detail is worth noticing. Why would a careful projection come in lower than last year? Because the file is shrinking. At these rates, the shelter starts next year with 825 repeat donors instead of 900. Nobody would see that in a budget spreadsheet. It shows up immediately when you build from donors.

The percentages on major gifts and grants are judgment calls. That's fine. The point is to make the judgment visible so someone can question it. "We think there's an 85% chance our nine major donors renew at last year's level" is a statement a board member can push back on. "We'll raise $540,000" isn't.

Explaining the number to your board

When you present the goal, show both numbers side by side: what the budget needs and what the donor file supports. Then walk the board through the table one line at a time. Seeing fundraising broken down this way changes the conversation. Instead of "Can development raise more?" the question becomes "Which of these lines do we believe we can move, and what would it take?"

Be ready for someone to say the assumptions are too conservative. Maybe they are. Ask them which line they'd change and why. If a board member thinks major gift renewals will hit 100%, ask whether they're willing to join the visits that make that more likely. The table turns a vague hope into a specific commitment.

If your board needs a broader framework for the year, an annual fundraising plan built around these same lines keeps the goal and the work connected.

When the bottom-up number is below the budget gap

This is where most organizations get into trouble. The tempting fix is to quietly raise the assumptions until the total matches the budget. Bump retention to 75%, double the new donors, call every major prospect a sure thing. The spreadsheet balances and the problem moves to next October.

Look at what closing the gap would actually take. The $90,200 shortfall is about 42% of the shelter's entire individual giving projection. Some of the obvious fixes help, but less than you'd think. Raising first-year retention from 30% to 40% adds 45 donors and about $5,400. That's worth doing, and the payoff grows over several years as those donors keep giving, but it won't close a $90,000 gap this year. A new monthly giving push that signs up 40 donors at $25 a month by the end of March produces about $9,000 over the remaining nine months, and some of that replaces gifts those donors would have made anyway.

When the gap is real, the honest options usually look like this:

  • Add a specific new initiative with its own line. A new major donor prospect list the board commits to working, a specific grant, a monthly giving program launch. Each gets its own assumptions and an owner, so it can be tracked.
  • Reduce expenses or phase them. Delay the new hire until midyear, or make a program expansion contingent on hitting a revenue milestone.
  • Plan the use of reserves deliberately. If the board decides to draw on reserves, make it a decision, not something discovered in the year-end audit.
  • Accept the risk out loud. Sometimes a board chooses an aggressive goal. That can be reasonable if everyone agrees it's a stretch and knows what happens if it falls short.

What doesn't work is pretending the gap isn't there. A development director who is handed an unreachable number often spends the year chasing it and the next year looking for a new job.

Build your first bottom-up number this week

Pull last year's donors and split them into repeat donors and first-year donors. Find out how many of each gave again, what they gave, and how many new donors you've added in each of the last three years. Then list your major donors and grants by name and status.

You'll have a rough bottom-up number in an afternoon. Put it next to the budget. If they're close, you've confirmed your goal is grounded. If they're far apart, you've found out in time to do something about it, which is much better than finding out in December.

While you're looking at who didn't give again, it's worth reading why donors stop giving. Every point of retention you gain makes next year's bottom-up number easier to build.

Once you have a goal, the next step is the plan to reach it. Here's how to write a fundraising plan.

Questions fundraisers ask

How do you set a fundraising goal?

Build it from the bottom up. For each source of revenue, ask who is going to give and how much is reasonable to expect from them, using your own retention rates and donor counts.

What's wrong with using the budget gap as the goal?

Nobody has asked whether your donor file can produce that number. The goal is whatever is left after expenses, and it may have no connection to what your donors have done before.

What if the bottom-up number is lower than what the budget needs?

Show the board both numbers side by side. Close a real gap with new initiatives, cuts or a planned use of reserves. Don't quietly raise the assumptions until the total matches.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedbudgetfundraising plangoalsplanning

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside