Non-Cash Gifts
Donor-Advised Funds Are Growing. Can Your Donors Actually Give From Theirs?
Your DAF donors have already decided to give. The question is where. Here's how DAF gifts work from the donor's side, and the fixes a small development shop can make before December.

Somewhere in your donor file is a person who has already set money aside for charity, already taken the tax deduction for it, and is now deciding where it goes. That person has a donor-advised fund. At a lot of small nonprofits, their gift shows up once a year as a check from Fidelity Charitable or a community foundation, gets entered under the sponsor's name, and earns a tax receipt the donor can't use.
DAFs are big enough now that this is a real problem. The 2025 Annual DAF Report, which the DAF Research Collaborative took over after National Philanthropic Trust published it for nearly two decades, found that DAFs granted $64.9 billion to charities in 2024. Contributions into DAFs reached $89.6 billion, and assets hit about $326 billion.
This article covers how a DAF gift works from the donor's side, the rules that trip nonprofits up, and the fixes a one- or two-person development shop can make before December.
What the numbers mean for a small nonprofit
That $326 billion isn't money waiting for you. It's money that belongs to sponsoring charities and moves out only when donors recommend grants. The report put the overall payout rate at 25.3%, meaning 2024 grants equaled about a quarter of DAF assets.
The account count needs a little care. The report counted roughly 3.56 million DAF accounts, but most of those are small accounts held by "donation processor" platforms. Excluding them, there were about 710,000 accounts at traditional sponsors like national DAF providers and community foundations.
For you, the important part is this: a DAF donor has already decided to give. The open question is where. That makes the moment they log in to recommend grants, which for many people is late in the year, one of the most important moments in your year-end campaign. If your organization is hard to find, hard to give to, or slow to say thank you, the money goes to a charity that made it easy.
How a DAF gift works from the donor's side
First, the donor puts cash or stock into their fund and takes the charitable deduction then. The IRS is clear that once the contribution is made, the sponsoring organization has legal control of the money. The donor keeps advisory privileges, which is why you'll hear people say a donor "recommends" a grant rather than makes one.
Second, sometime later, the donor logs in and searches for your organization, usually by name or EIN. If your legal name differs from the name on your letterhead, or a similarly named group in another state shows up first, this is where gifts get lost or misdirected.
Third, the sponsor reviews and approves the grant, then pays it. Fidelity Charitable, for example, mails checks to the address on your IRS Form 990 unless you've enrolled in electronic payments, which it says arrive in one to two days.
Fourth, you receive money from the sponsor, with the donor's name and address only if the donor chose to share them. Most do. Fidelity Charitable says only 4% of its grants are anonymous.
Four rules that catch nonprofits off guard
You don't send a tax receipt. The donor already took the deduction when they funded the account. Fidelity Charitable tells nonprofits to remove any acknowledgment language that implies a deduction and to make clear the letter is not a tax receipt.
Your year-end tax argument doesn't apply. "Give before December 31 to get your deduction" means nothing to someone recommending a DAF grant, because the deduction is already behind them. What still applies is the reason most people give at year-end anyway: they want to finish their giving and feel good about where it went. Write the DAF line in your appeal around impact, not taxes.
The grant can't buy benefits. Schwab Charitable's guidance says grants can't pay for event tickets the donor will use, even if the donor covers the non-deductible portion separately. If your year-end push includes a gala table or a membership with benefits, point DAF donors to a straight gift instead.
Pledges are complicated. Fidelity Charitable says a grant can't fulfill a legally binding pledge. Its reasoning: the tax code bars DAF grants that give the donor more than an incidental benefit, and Fidelity treats relieving a donor's financial obligation as one. Schwab Charitable lists legally binding pre-existing commitments among grants it won't make. The IRS floated a more flexible approach in Notice 2017-73 and said taxpayers could rely on it until further guidance, but sponsors' own policies remain stricter. If you run multi-year pledges or a capital campaign, Fidelity suggests a non-binding letter of intent that states the donor "intends to recommend" a grant. Have your own counsel review your pledge forms.
Five fixes to make before December
1. Build a DAF giving page. Put your legal name exactly as the IRS lists it, your EIN, and the mailing address that matches your Form 990. Add a suggested purpose line ("Year-end 2026: general support"), ask donors to share their name and address with you when they recommend the grant, and name a staff person they can email. Link it from your donation page and your year-end reply device.
2. Add a DAF option to your online form. Tools now exist that let a donor recommend a grant without leaving your giving page. Chariot's DAFpay is one: the donor selects their DAF provider, logs in, and submits a grant request from your form, and Chariot says it shares donor-confirmed name and email with you in real time. Ask your donation platform whether it supports DAFpay or something similar and what it costs before you commit.
3. Mention DAFs in your appeal. One line in the P.S. is enough:
"If you give through a donor-advised fund, you can recommend a grant to [Legal Name], EIN [XX-XXXXXXX]. Our DAF page at [URL] has everything your fund sponsor needs."
4. Fix how DAF gifts land in your database. This is where small shops lose the most. Imagine a literacy program with about 1,200 donors. A retired teacher gave $250 by check three years running. This year she moved her giving to a DAF and recommended a $1,000 grant. The gift gets entered under "Fidelity Charitable," she looks lapsed, and in February she receives your "we miss you" letter. She just quadrupled her gift.
Many organizations handle this by recording the payment from the sponsor and soft-crediting the recommending donor, so the person's giving history stays whole. Whatever your system calls it, the test is simple: when you pull last year's top donors, does she appear? Add a "gives through DAF" flag too, so you can send that group their own year-end reminder in early December.
5. Thank the person, not the sponsor. Fidelity Charitable is direct about this: thank the donor who recommended the grant, not Fidelity. Mail sent to the sponsor won't be forwarded. Thank DAF donors as quickly as any other donor (the 48-hour follow-up rule applies here too), and write the letter for them:
"Thank you for recommending a $1,000 grant to us from your donor-advised fund. Because of you, 14 second graders will finish the school year with a reading tutor who knows their name. Since your gift came through your fund, this letter isn't a tax receipt; your fund sponsor has your records. But we wanted you to hear directly what your generosity is doing."
That letter treats the gift as personal generosity, not an institutional grant. Many DAF donors are among your most generous supporters, so they belong in the same personal stewardship you'd give any major donor.
Where to start this week
Pull every gift you've received in the last three years from a DAF sponsor. Search your database for names like Fidelity Charitable, Schwab Charitable, Vanguard Charitable, National Philanthropic Trust, and your local community foundation. For each gift, answer three questions. Is it credited to the person who recommended it? Did that person get a real thank-you, or a tax receipt they couldn't use? Is that person on your year-end appeal list under their own name?
If the answers are messy, you've found donors who are probably more committed than your file shows. Fix their records, build the DAF page, and add the P.S. line before your appeal drops. It's a few hours of work for donors who have already decided to give.
If you want a structured way to fit fixes like these into the rest of your year-end plan, the Finish Strong workbook walks you through a 13-week October-to-December calendar, with worksheets that build into a complete year-end campaign plan. It's written for small teams that need the plan finished.
For how DAF gifts fit alongside bequests, IRA gifts and other legacy gifts, see the guide to planned giving.
Questions fundraisers ask
How does a donor-advised fund gift work?
The donor puts cash or stock into the fund and takes the charitable deduction then. The sponsoring organization has legal control of the money, and the donor recommends grants from it. You receive the money from the sponsor, with the donor's name only if the donor chose to share it.
Do you send a tax receipt for a DAF gift?
No. The donor took the deduction when they funded the account. Thank the donor who recommended the grant directly, and soft-credit that person in your database.
How do you make it easy for donors to give from a DAF?
Build a DAF giving page with your exact legal name, your EIN and the address on your Form 990.
Ask a fundraiser




