Fundraising

Year-End Giving Campaign Ideas for Small Teams

Eight campaign ideas a small team can run between Giving Tuesday and December 31, what each one takes, and how to pick the two or three worth your hours.

The year-end giving campaign ideas that work for a small team have one thing in common: they reuse the same offer. A matching gift from your board, personal asks to your top donors, a thank-you night and three short emails in the last days of December can all run on one story, one ask and one deadline. You don't need all of them. Between Giving Tuesday and December 31, a team of one or two can run two or three well.

Below are eight ideas, what each one takes in hours, money and people, and how to choose.

Why a small team should pick fewer ideas

At Food for the Hungry, we once took the donors who had given through our Christmas gift catalog during the previous year's fourth quarter and sorted them by what they'd given: chickens, goats, school fees. Then we wrote a separate email for each group, so someone who had given chickens got an email about chickens. It was a lot of work, and we expected it to pay off.

It didn't. The segmented emails didn't raise more money than the general gift catalog emails we sent to everyone.

I still personalize. I'm more careful about how much work it gets. Where I might once have made twelve versions of a gift catalog email, today I might make four. I've written more about which kinds of donor personalization are worth the work.

We had a team to do that work, and it still didn't earn its place. On a team of one or two, every idea you add takes hours away from another one. So judge each idea below by what it's likely to return for the hours it takes, and expect to say no to most of them.

One decision makes every idea cheaper. Settle on a single offer for the whole month: one person's story, one specific need with a price on it and the December 31 deadline. If you haven't built that yet, start with a year-end offer donors can finish and the year-end appeal letter that carries it. Every idea here reuses that offer, so you write the hard part once.

Eight year-end giving campaign ideas and what each one takes

The hours are planning estimates for an organization with fewer than 2,000 donors. Adjust them for your own file.

Idea

Hours

Cost

Who does it

1. A board matching gift

About 3, mostly phone calls

None

Executive director or board chair

2. Personal asks to your top 25 donors

About 8, at 15 to 20 minutes a donor

None

You and the executive director

3. A thank-you night

About 4, half of it preparation

Cards and stamps

Four to six board members or volunteers

4. Notes to last December's donors

About 4 for 50 notes

Cards and stamps

You

5. A five-item giving list

About 4

None

You and a program lead

6. Ten supporters who forward one email

About 2

None

You and ten supporters

7. A ways-to-give reminder

About 2

None

You and whoever keeps the books

8. Three emails for December 29, 30 and 31

About 3, done by December 15

None

You

1. A matching gift from your board

Ask your board members and two or three close donors to pool a matching fund, then tell everyone else their gift will be matched through December 31. The money doesn't have to come from one person. Say five board members each put in $1,000. You have a $5,000 match.

It isn't too late to add one after the campaign has started. One year at World Concern, our first year-end email fell flat. We suspected a match would help, found a small one and tested it in the next email. The results were much better, so we asked board members and other key supporters to build a larger matching fund and used it for the rest of the campaign.

Be honest about which kind you have. In a true match, the money is only given if you raise the rest. In a challenge, it's committed either way. Tell donors which one you're running. If some board members can't put money into the match, give them one of these year-end jobs for board members.

2. Personal asks to your top 25 donors

A few donors give most of the money. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's data through June 2026, donors who gave $5,000 or more made up 2.9% of donors and gave 76.4% of the dollars. A small organization may not have many $5,000 donors, but the pattern usually holds at a smaller scale.

So pick your top 25 donors and have a person call or visit each one with a specific request. Ask how they'd like to give, because gifts from an IRA, a donor-advised fund or stock take time to arrive. If your appeal has already mailed, call anyway and tell them you wanted to follow up on the letter personally.

3. A thank-you night before the final asks

Pick one evening in the second week of December. Put four to six board members or volunteers in a room with a list of the people who have given since January, a short script and a stack of cards. They call or write to say thank you, and they don't ask for anything.

Your donors will get several asks from you before December 31. This puts a thank-you in the middle of them, from a person, with nothing attached. It's also a good job for board members who resist asking. These donor thank-you call scripts include a voicemail version, since many of the calls will go to voicemail.

4. Handwritten notes to last December's donors

Pull everyone who gave last December and hasn't given since. They've already shown they give at year-end, which is why your year-end appeal starts with last December's donors. Write each one a short note. Thank them for that gift, tell them one thing it did and repeat the offer.

Keep the list recent. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 data, only 3% of donors who had already lapsed gave again. Long-lapsed donors are a poor use of December hours. If you want to go further back, use a break-even calculation to decide which lapsed donors to mail.

5. A five-item giving list

A full gift catalog is a big project. A list of five items is an afternoon. Sit down with a program lead and price the five things you most need before spring, then put them on one page. Say an after-school tutoring program lists $25 for a month of snacks for one student, $60 for a set of books for a reading group and three more items up to $500.

Specific asks work. In Bloomerang's Giving Signals 2026 survey, 94% of donors said they're motivated when they're told exactly where the money will go. Use real costs, and say plainly whether a gift buys that exact item or supports the program the item represents.

6. Ten supporters who each forward one email

December is the wrong month to launch a peer-to-peer platform. You can still borrow the idea. Choose ten people who already care about your work, such as volunteers, monthly donors and board members. Write a short email about your offer, then ask each one personally to forward it to five friends with a line of their own.

The donors this brings in tend to be new to you. In platform data from GivingTuesday and GoFundMe Pro, 77% of donors who gave through peer-to-peer campaigns were new to the organization, compared with 56% for other kinds of campaigns. If it goes well, plan a full peer-to-peer fundraising campaign for a calmer month.

7. A ways-to-give reminder for IRA, fund and stock donors

Some of your donors want to give from somewhere other than a checking account, and many of them do it at the end of the year. Vanguard Charitable reported that $953 million of the $3.9 billion in grants its donors made in 2025 went out between November 1 and December 31. That's about a quarter of the year's total in two months.

Send one plain email in the first half of December that explains how to give from a donor-advised fund, by stock transfer and, for donors 70½ and older, straight from an IRA. Include your legal name, tax ID number and mailing address, and the name of a person to call with questions. Have whoever keeps your books check it before it goes out. I've covered the details in how to ask for QCD gifts before December 31 and how to make it easy to give from a DAF.

8. Three short emails for December 29, 30 and 31

The last three days of the year deserve their own plan. In the M+R Benchmarks study of 2025 giving, the last week of the year brought in 10% of annual online revenue, and December 31 alone brought in 4%.

People giving in those last days have mostly decided already, so the emails can be short: the offer, the match if you have one, the deadline and a link. Take anyone who has given since December 1 off the list and thank them instead. Test your donation page on a phone. Then write and schedule all three by December 15, because nobody writes well on December 30. The full plan is in the last 72 hours of December.

How to choose your two or three

Start with how many hours you can honestly give to fundraising in December, then match the ideas to the hours.

  • If you have about 15 hours for the whole month: the board match, the top 25 asks and the three final emails. By my estimates that's 14 hours, and all three share one offer.
  • If you have 20 to 25 hours: add the thank-you night and the notes to last December's donors. Your board does most of the work on the first one.
  • If your board will work but your email list is small: the match, the thank-you night and the notes. With a few hundred donors, you can reach nearly everyone by card or phone.

Giving Tuesday falls on December 1 in 2026. For most small teams, I'd treat it as the day you announce the match, in an email you were already going to send, and not as a separate campaign. If you're unsure, work through whether your small nonprofit should do Giving Tuesday.

A sample December for a team of one

Say you're the only fundraiser at an after-school tutoring program with 600 donors, and you've picked the match, the top 25 asks, the thank-you night and the final emails. That's about 18 hours of work across the month.

  • By December 1: five board members have pledged $1,000 each. Announce the $5,000 match in your Giving Tuesday email.
  • December 1 to 11: you and the executive director call the top 25, about three calls a day.
  • December 10: the board meets for the thank-you night.
  • December 15: the three final emails are written and scheduled, and you've made a test gift on your phone.
  • December 17: compare your results with last December's. If you're behind, there's still time to fix your year-end campaign.
  • December 29, 30 and 31: the emails go out. Each morning, remove anyone who gave the day before.
  • First week of January: every donor is thanked, and new donors get a welcome.

What I'd leave for another year

Some good ideas are wrong for December. A new text messaging program is one. In M+R's study, nonprofits raised $0.09 by text for every dollar they raised by email, and you can only text people who gave you permission. I've written about when texting donors at year-end helps.

A new event, a new giving platform and a dozen audience segments belong in the same pile. Each of them can work. None of them can be built well in four weeks by someone who is also answering the phone.

Start with the offer and your hours

Write your offer sentence first: "Your gift of [amount] by December 31 will [result]." Add up the hours you really have in December. Then circle two or three ideas in the table and cross out the rest.

For the full calendar from October through January, see the year-end fundraising guide. If you'd like worksheets for the whole season, the Finish Strong workbook lays out all 13 weeks from October to December. And for ideas that need more than a month, I keep a longer list of fundraising ideas for nonprofits.

Questions fundraisers ask

How many year-end campaigns should a small nonprofit run?

One. A small nonprofit should run a single year-end campaign built on one offer, then add two or three ideas that reuse it, such as a board match, personal asks to top donors and a short email series in the last days of December. Separate campaigns with separate themes split your hours and give donors several messages to sort out during the busiest giving month of the year.

What year-end fundraising ideas cost nothing?

A board matching gift, personal asks to your largest donors and a short email series cost nothing but time. Ask board members to pool a match, call your top 25 donors with a specific request, and schedule three emails for December 29, 30 and 31. Together they take about 14 hours across the month for an organization with fewer than 2,000 donors.

Is December too late to start a year-end giving campaign?

No. A large share of online giving arrives at the very end of the month. In the M+R Benchmarks study of 2025 giving, the last week of the year brought in 10% of annual online revenue and December 31 brought in 4%. Even in mid-December you can call your top donors, add a match and schedule emails for the final three days.

How do you find a matching gift donor for a year-end campaign?

Ask your board members first, then two or three of your closest donors. The match doesn't have to come from one person, so five gifts of $1,000 make a $5,000 matching fund. Tell donors honestly whether it's a true match, where the money is only given if you raise the rest, or a challenge, where it's committed either way.

How do you set a goal for a year-end giving campaign?

Start with what you raised last December, broken out by source: mail, email and your largest donors. Then add what each new idea can reasonably bring, such as the amount of your match or the gifts you expect from personal asks. A goal built from your own numbers is one you can explain to your board and track week by week during December.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedcampaignsmatchsmall nonprofitsyear end

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside