Appeals

Your Year-End Appeal Starts With Last December's Donors

Last December's donors are the most valuable people on your file, and most of them hear nothing from you until the next appeal. Here's how to pull that list and warm it up in October and November.

Before you write a word of this year's year-end appeal, pull one list: everyone who gave to your organization between December 1 and December 31 of last year.

For most nonprofits, that list holds the most valuable donors on the file. They've already shown you they give at the end of the year, and many of them will do it again. Yet in a lot of organizations, the first thing those donors hear since last year's receipt is this year's appeal.

If the appeal is the first real contact in ten months, it arrives cold. If it's the third contact, it arrives as the next part of a story the donor already knows. This article walks through how to pull last December's donors, how to sort them, and what to send them in October and November so your ask lands warm.

Why last December's donors need their own plan

December carries more weight than any other month. The Blackbaud Institute's 2025 Trends in Giving data found that December alone accounted for roughly 18% of annual giving, and more than 36% of charitable revenue came in during the fourth quarter. Online, the concentration is sharper. The 2026 M+R Benchmarks Study found nonprofits received 37% of their 2025 online revenue in December, with 10% arriving in the last week of the year and 4% on December 31 alone.

Those numbers tell you when giving happens. They don't tell you who's doing it. A big share of December gifts comes from people with a year-end habit. Some are thinking about taxes. Some decide on gifts as a family over the holidays. Some simply respond when asked, and you've always asked in December.

Whatever the reason, past behavior is the best predictor you have. The same M+R study found retention of 66% for prior online donors compared with 24% for new online donors. Someone who has already given to you is far more likely to give again than someone who hasn't.

So the question isn't whether last December's donors will get your appeal. They will. The question is whether they hear anything before it that makes them want to say yes again.

How to pull the list and what to look for

Run a gift report for December 1 through December 31 of last year. Export it with these columns: donor name, gift amount, gift date, channel (mail, online, in person), designation, date of first-ever gift, and number of gifts since last December.

Then sort into three groups.

December regulars. They gave last December and the December before. These are your most predictable donors and often the least thanked, because everyone assumes they'll give.

Last year's December first-timers. Their first gift ever came last December. These are your riskiest donors. New donor retention is low across the sector, and if all they've received since is a receipt and a few newsletters, they may barely remember why they gave.

Your largest December gifts. Pick a cutoff that fits your file, perhaps your top 20 or 30 gifts. These donors deserve a personal touch on top of a good letter.

Then look at the "gifts since" column. Anyone who has given again since December is already engaged. Anyone who hasn't is the person you most need to reach before the appeal goes out.

Imagine a hypothetical animal shelter with 2,100 active donors. Last December, 410 people gave. When the part-time development director sorts the list, she finds 190 December regulars, 150 first-time December donors, and 25 gifts of $500 or more. Of the 150 first-timers, 118 haven't given since. That's a sobering number, and it's also a clear to-do list for October.

October: close the loop on last year's gift

The first contact should look backward. Tell December donors what their gift did.

Make it specific to the gift, not a recap of everything your organization accomplished this year. If they gave to the shelter's winter medical fund, tell them about the animals who got surgery in the months that followed. If you can't tie outcomes to a gift that precisely, tie it to the season:

"When you gave last December, we were heading into the coldest months of the year with every kennel full. I wanted you to know what happened next. Between January and March, 64 dogs and cats who came in sick or injured went home healthy. Your gift was part of that."

A one-page letter with a photo works well. So does a short email. For your largest December donors, a phone call from the executive director or a board member beats both. Keep the call free of any ask. Thank them and share one thing their gift made possible. If time is the obstacle, the approach in The 15-Minute Partnership fits these calls well.

Should this piece include a reply envelope? I'd leave it out. The purpose is to show the donor their last decision was a good one. Add an envelope and many donors will read it as an appeal, which undercuts the point. A quiet donate link at the bottom of an email is fine.

For the first-timers, add a line acknowledging that they chose you: "Last December, 150 people gave to the shelter for the first time. You were one of them, and I'm grateful." It costs nothing, and it signals that someone noticed.

November: give them a reason to expect your letter

October looks back. November looks ahead. Choose one of these, not all three:

  • A preview note. "In a few weeks you'll hear from us about this winter's medical fund. Because you gave last December, I wanted you to hear about it first." This makes the appeal feel like a follow-up instead of an interruption.
  • A one-question email. "What made you decide to give last December?" The replies are useful twice: donors feel heard, and you learn the language to use in the appeal.
  • A handwritten card. A Thanksgiving card signed by a board member, with one sentence about last year's gift.

For your largest donors, a short personal note or second call letting them know the year-end appeal is coming is a courtesy, and it gives them room to tell you if they plan to give differently this year.

December: write the appeal to people who already know you

When the appeal goes out, these donors should get a version that acknowledges their history. Open with their gift, not your need: "Last December, you helped us get through the hardest months of the year." Then connect it to what you told them in October. For more on framing the ask around what the donor makes possible, see Stop Telling Donors What You Need.

Two practical details matter here. First, base the ask amount on their last gift. If someone gave $100 last December, a reply device that suggests $25 leaves money on the table, and one that suggests $1,000 tells them you don't know who they are. Second, match the timing to how they gave. Mail donors need the letter in hand in early December. Online donors who gave on December 29 last year should get an email in that same window this year.

A calendar a small shop can actually run

  • Mid-October: Pull the list, sort the three groups, check gifts since.
  • Late October: Send the impact letter or email. Make calls to your largest December donors.
  • Mid-November: Send the preview note, question, or card.
  • Late November to early December: Mail the appeal with a version for last year's December donors.
  • December 26 to 31: Send a final email to December donors who haven't given yet.

That's four or five touches across ten weeks, and only one of them asks for money. If some of last December's first-timers still don't give, look at what they experienced after their first gift. Why Your Donors Stopped Giving is a good place to start that diagnosis.

Start this week. Pull the list before you start drafting the letter, because the list should shape the letter.

If you'd like a structured way to plan the whole season, Finish Strong: The 90-Day Year-End Fundraising Plan is a workbook that walks you through a year-end campaign from October through December on a 13-week calendar. Each step has a worksheet, and by the end the worksheets add up to a complete year-end plan, with AI prompts along the way to speed up the drafting.

Questions fundraisers ask

Who should you contact first before a year-end appeal?

Everyone who gave between December 1 and December 31 of last year. Pull that list before you write a word of this year's appeal.

What should you send last December's donors in October?

A report on what their gift accomplished, with no ask attached. In November, give them a reason to expect your letter.

How should the appeal to last year's donors be different?

Open with their gift and what it did. Then base each donor's ask amounts on what they gave last time.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedappealsfourth quarterretentionyear end

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside