Direct Mail
How to Write a Year-End Appeal Letter (With Example)
The six parts of a year-end appeal letter, a full example you can adapt, and how to change it for current donors, lapsed donors and prospects.

A year-end appeal letter has one job: to get someone who already cares about your work to give before December 31. The letters that do it tell the story of one person, ask for a specific gift that solves a specific problem and name the deadline. The letters that fall short usually spend their two pages on the organization's year instead.
Below are the parts of the letter, a full example you can adapt, and how to change it for current donors, lapsed donors and people who have never given.
Why the year-end letter deserves your best writing
December is when a large share of giving gets decided. The Blackbaud Institute found that about 18% of all giving in 2025 arrived in December and 36.1% arrived in the fourth quarter. Online giving is even more concentrated. In M+R's 2026 Benchmarks, 37% of the year's online revenue came in during December, and 10% came in the last week of the year. Those are different measures, one of all giving and one of online gifts only, so don't add them together.
The letter also does more than bring back checks. A Giving USA Foundation report on donor confidence, cited in the Douglas Shaw and Fundraise Up faith sector report, found that donors who receive fundraising mail are twice as likely to give online as to send back the reply card. So the story, the amounts and the deadline in your letter should match what the donor finds on your donation page.
Write about the donor, not your organization
Shortly after I joined Food for the Hungry, I moved our email fundraising away from an expensive outside agency and brought it in-house. At first the results were disappointing. Our team was inexperienced, and we wrote appeals about our programs and how effective the organization was. We weren't writing about the donor and the difference they could make. We had to learn to make the donor the central participant in the story.
That was email, but a letter fails the same way. Compare two sentences from a made-up family shelter:
- "Our shelter served 412 families in 2026 through our three core programs."
- "Your gift will give a family a safe place to sleep tonight."
Both can be true. The first reports on the organization. The second tells the reader what their gift will do.
Here's a quick check for your draft. Circle every "we" and "our," then circle every "you" and "your." If the first group is bigger, rewrite the letter until the reader shows up more often than the organization does.
The six parts of a year-end appeal letter
1. A first line that starts inside the story
Skip the warm-up. "As the year draws to a close" could open any letter from any organization. Start with a person at a moment the reader can picture: "On the first cold night in November, Dana parked behind the grocery store." Address the letter to the donor by name if your data is clean enough to trust.
2. One person's story
Build the letter around one person, by name, with their permission. If you've changed the name to protect someone, say so. In my own testing, story has consistently beaten statistics. I can't remember a test where the statistic won. Numbers still have a place. They show the size of the need and help a donor trust that the work is real. Put them behind the person, not in front.
3. The need that's still unmet
Don't finish the story so neatly that nothing is left for the donor to do. If the person in your letter has already been helped, tell the donor that gifts like theirs made it possible, then turn to the next person who is waiting. The donor has to see the gap their gift will fill.
4. A specific ask
Name the amount, what it does and the date: "Your gift of $90 by December 31 will give a family two safe nights." In Bloomerang's Giving Signals 2026 survey, 94% of donors chose a specific appeal over a vague one. Base the amounts on what each donor has given before. I've written separately about how to choose ask amounts for your year-end appeal.
Put the first ask on page one. A reader who stops there should still know what you want them to do. Then ask again near the close.
5. A reason to give now
December 31 is a real deadline, because gifts made by then count for that tax year. Say it plainly. If you have a matching gift, put it near the top, and only if the match is real. Starting in 2026, donors who don't itemize can deduct cash gifts again, so it's worth a line about the new charitable deduction. Pair the date with a reason that comes from the need, such as winter coming or shelves that empty after the holidays.
6. A P.S. that repeats the ask
Direct mail writers have long treated the P.S. as one of the most-read parts of a letter. Write it as if it's the only part someone will read: the amount, what it does and the deadline.
The letter doesn't travel alone. It goes out with a reply card, and your reply card is doing more work than your letter. The amounts and the wording of the offer should match on both pieces. Use short paragraphs, wide margins and type of at least 12 points so the page is easy to read.
A year-end appeal letter example
Here's a complete letter for a made-up organization, Maple Street Family Shelter. The people, numbers and costs are invented for the example. Swap in your own story and your own costs, and keep every claim true. Only say you turned families away if you did.
Dear Susan,
On the first cold night in November, Dana parked behind the grocery store, tucked blankets around her two children in the back seat and stayed awake so they could sleep.
Three weeks earlier, her hours had been cut and she'd lost the apartment. Caleb is nine. Lily is six. Dana told us the hardest part was Lily asking every night when they were going home.
I'm writing because there are parents like Dana in our town tonight, and you can give one of them a safe place to bring their children.
Your gift of $90 will give a family two nights at Maple Street Family Shelter: a private room with a door that locks, three meals a day and a caseworker who starts helping them find housing the next morning.
Dana and her children came to us the week before Thanksgiving. They had a room that night because people like you gave. In January she starts a new job, and her caseworker is helping her apply for an apartment near Caleb's school.
But the family who needs the next room hasn't arrived yet. Winter is when our rooms fill. Last January we had to turn 14 families away because every bed was taken. I don't want to tell another mother there's no room.
It costs $45 to give one family one safe night. Would you send $90, $225 or whatever you can by December 31? Use the enclosed card and envelope, or give online at [your web address].
Thank you for caring about families like Dana's.
Gratefully,
Maria Alvarez
Executive DirectorP.S. Every $45 gives a family a safe night this winter. Please send your gift by December 31 so a room is ready when the next family comes.
What the example does
- It opens with Dana. The shelter isn't named until the fourth paragraph, and by then the reader knows why it matters.
- The donor gets the credit. Dana had a room "because people like you gave."
- The story turns to the next family. Dana is safe, so the letter moves to the people who aren't yet.
- There is one price. Everything is built on $45 a night, so $90 and $225 are easy to picture as two nights and five nights.
- The ask appears three times: in the fourth paragraph, near the close and in the P.S.
- The deadline has a reason behind it. December 31 is paired with winter and full rooms.
Adapt the letter for donors, lapsed donors and prospects
Keep the story and the ask the same for every group. Change the opening, the amounts and how much you're willing to spend.
The spending matters because the returns are so different. In M+R's 2026 Benchmarks, direct mail to active donors returned $4.51 for every dollar spent. Mail to lapsed donors returned $0.90, and mail to prospects returned $0.41. Mail to current donors pays for itself several times over. Mail to the other two groups, on average, costs more than it brings back, so you send it to gain or regain a donor, not to make money on that mailing.
Reader | What to change | The ask |
|---|---|---|
Current donors | Thank them near the top for giving, and name the gift if your data is reliable | Start at their most recent gift, rounded to a clean number |
Lapsed donors | Acknowledge that they gave before and tell them what it did. Don't scold | Start at their last gift, never above it |
Prospects | Add two or three sentences on who you are and why they're hearing from you | One modest amount tied to one result |
Here's how the opening of the example changes for each group.
Current donors: "Because you gave last December, a mother named Dana and her two children had a safe place to sleep." Start your list with the people who gave at the end of the previous year, because your year-end appeal starts with last December's donors. Your largest donors shouldn't get this letter first. Pick your top 25 donors and ask them personally before the appeal goes out.
Lapsed donors: "You gave to Maple Street in 2024, and families slept safely because of it. I'm writing because families need you again." How far back you go is a math question. Use a break-even calculation to decide which lapsed donors to mail.
Prospects: "You may never have met Dana, but she lives in your town." For a small organization, the best prospects are people who already know you: volunteers, event guests and newsletter readers who haven't given. Cold lists are expensive. TrueSense Marketing estimates that it now costs about $90 to $120 to acquire a donor by mail.
Mail it early, then follow up
Plan for the letter to arrive in late November or the first week of December. That leaves time for a second mailing, and the follow-up letter needs its own plan. Repeat the same story and ask in your year-end emails, especially in the last week of December, when so much online giving arrives.
Two housekeeping items protect the gifts you've earned. Date December donations correctly, because a check mailed on December 30 belongs in December. And have your donor thank-you letter written before the first gift comes in, so no one waits weeks to hear from you.
Start with the story and the ask sentence
Before you draft anything else, do two things. Choose the one person your letter is about and get their permission. Then write the ask sentence: "Your gift of [amount] by December 31 will [result]." If you can't fill in both brackets yet, settle the offer before you write the letter. Then draft the letter around the story and the ask, write the reply card to match and read the whole thing aloud before it goes to the printer.
The letter is one piece of the season. For the full plan from October through January, see the year-end fundraising guide, and for the rest of the mail package, the direct mail fundraising guide. If you'd like worksheets for the whole campaign, the Finish Strong workbook lays out all 13 weeks from October to December.
Questions fundraisers ask
How long should a year-end appeal letter be?
Two pages is a good length for most year-end appeal letters. What matters more than length is how easy the letter is to read: short paragraphs, wide margins and type of at least 12 points. Don't cut the story or shrink the type to fit one page. A crowded single page is harder to read than two open ones.
When should you mail a year-end appeal letter?
Mail your year-end appeal letter so it arrives in late November or the first week of December. That gives donors time to respond and gives you time to send a follow-up letter and emails before December 31. Holiday mail can be slow, so confirm print and delivery times early. A letter that lands after Christmas leaves little time to give by mail.
Who should sign a year-end appeal letter?
One person should sign it, usually the executive director or whoever your donors know best. A letter reads as personal when it comes from one person and uses "I." A list of names or a board signature block makes it read like an institutional notice. Use a real signature, in blue ink if you can print it that way.
Should a year-end appeal letter mention tax deductions?
Yes, briefly. A sentence reminding donors that gifts made by December 31 count for that tax year is enough. Starting in 2026, donors who don't itemize can deduct cash gifts again, up to $1,000 for single filers and $2,000 for married couples filing jointly. Keep the story as the main reason to give, and suggest donors check with their own tax advisor.
Can you send a year-end appeal letter by email?
You can use the same story and ask, but rewrite it for email. An email should be much shorter than the letter, with the ask and a donation link near the top. Send several emails across December, since one email is easy to miss, and keep the story, amount and deadline consistent with the letter your donors received in the mail.
Ask a fundraiser




