Donor Communication
Personalized Donor Communication: What Works and What Isn't Worth the Effort
Personal touches keep donors giving, but more segments don't automatically raise more money. What personalization is worth doing, what isn't, and how a small team can do it well.

When was the last time a nonprofit truly surprised you? For me, it was a gift I made to Medical Teams International. I got the standard email thank-you and receipt, and then a receipt in the mail. Then I received a long, handwritten thank-you note. Nobody had to do that. Somebody decided I was worth the time.
That's personalization at its best. It isn't a mail-merge field. It's the sense that a real person noticed you.
Why personalization matters more now
There are fewer donors to go around. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project found the number of donors fell 3.6% in 2025, a fifth straight year of decline. But the donors who stay are worth more: the Virtuous 2026 benchmark found lifetime value rose 18% among retained donors, and the median gift rose 20%.
When every donor matters more, it's worth treating each one less like a row in a spreadsheet.
The personalization that works
A handwritten note. A note from the president of an organization takes a few minutes and tells a donor someone noticed their gift.
A personal note to someone who drifted away. Thank them for what they gave, tell them what's new and don't ask for anything.
Reporting in the donor's terms. Ask what a donor hopes to accomplish, and report on that. A donor who cares about children served should hear about children served.
A phone call. A short call to say thank you, with no ask, is one of the most personal things you can do, and one of the least common.
The personalization that isn't worth it
At Food for the Hungry, we segmented gift catalog donors by what they'd given the previous year and built targeted emails for each group: chicken donors got an email about chickens, goat donors got one about goats. It was a lot of work, and we expected a big improvement.
Those segmented emails raised no more money than the general catalog email we sent to everyone.
I didn't stop personalizing. I got more selective. Where I once might have built twelve versions of an email, today I might build four. More segments don't automatically mean more money, and AI now makes it easy to create dozens of versions that nobody needed.
Test it. If a segmented version doesn't beat the general version, keep the simpler one.
How a small team can personalize
- Use what you already know. Mention the donor's last gift, the program they supported or how long they've given.
- Personalize the moments that matter. First gifts, upgrades, anniversaries and lapses deserve a personal touch. Routine appeals often don't.
- Segment by behavior, not just demographics. First-time donors, monthly donors, lapsed donors and mid-level donors need different messages more than different age groups do. Here's how to segment your donors.
- Let the donor tell you. Ask new donors why they gave. Write the answer down and use it.
Where to start this week
Pick your 25 most generous donors from the last year. For each one, write down one thing you know about why they give. If you can't, that's your first conversation. Then send each of them a handwritten note that mentions it.
For the full picture, see the guide to donor retention.
Questions fundraisers ask
What is personalized donor communication?
Communication that reflects what you know about a donor: their name, their giving history and what they care about. It ranges from a merged greeting to a handwritten note or a report built around one donor's interests.
What kind of personalization works best?
The kind that comes from a person. A phone call, a handwritten note or an update on the specific project a donor supports usually does more than a dozen automated versions of an email.
How many segments should I create for an appeal?
Start with three or four groups that would receive a different message, such as current, monthly and lapsed donors. Add more only if testing shows it raises more than it costs in time.
How can a small team personalize without more staff?
Personalize the greeting, one line about the donor's history and the ask amount, and keep the rest the same. Save calls and handwritten notes for new donors, larger donors and donors who've stopped giving.
Ask a fundraiser




