Donor Relations
The 50-Name Exercise: How to Build Your First Prospect List in One Hour
You know more prospective donors than you think. This one-hour exercise uses six categories and a set of prompts to build your first list of 50 names, and shows you what to do with it.

Many nonprofit leaders believe they don't know enough people to raise money. Most know far more than they think. The names have never been written down in one place.
This exercise takes one hour. You need paper or a spreadsheet and a timer. If you haven't read it yet, start with why your best prospects already know you.
Why 50
Fifty is enough to work with and not so many that you put it off. If you contact ten people a month, 50 names is five months of conversations.
You also need more names than you think, because not everyone will respond. Some people will be busy. Some will say not now. A generous donor once told me they cared deeply about our work but had reached their giving limit for the year, and asked me to come back after the new year. We did, and they made a five-figure gift. When you only have five names, a "not now" feels like failure. With 50, it's a note on the calendar.
The rules
- Don't judge. Write the name even if you think they can't give or won't be interested.
- Don't research yet. No looking up addresses or employers. Names only.
- Keep moving. If a category runs dry, go to the next one and come back.
The six categories
Spend about ten minutes on each.
1. Past and current donors. Anyone who has ever given, at any amount. Put lapsed donors first.
2. Board and staff contacts. The friends, family, coworkers and neighbors of your board and staff. Ask each board member for five names.
3. Volunteers. Current and past. People who have given time have already decided your work matters.
4. People you've served. Alumni, parents, former clients and their families, where it's appropriate to contact them.
5. Community connections. Pastors, business owners, civic club members, vendors you pay and partner organizations.
6. Your own circle. Friends, family, old coworkers, people from church or school. Many founders skip this category because it feels awkward. These are the people most likely to say yes to you.
Prompts to jog your memory
- Who came to your last event?
- Who has ever asked how the organization is doing?
- Who sent a note, a comment or a reply to an email?
- Who introduced you to someone useful?
- Who used to be involved and drifted away?
- Who gives to a cause like yours?
- Whose kids, parents or friends have been helped by your work?
- Who would be sad if your organization closed?
Go through your phone contacts, your email inbox and your last three event lists. You'll find a dozen more.
What to do with your list
Add three columns. How they know you. Who on your team knows them best. What they seem to care about.
That third column matters more than it looks. Early in my career I took several couples on a field trip to see our work. With one couple, I hadn't learned beforehand whether the work matched their interests, and nothing I showed them connected. They gave less than I'd hoped. Find out what a person cares about before you plan what to ask them for.
Sort by closeness. Put the people most connected to your work at the top. Don't sort by how much money you think they have.
Choose ten. Contact the top ten this week with a note, a call or an invitation to coffee. Thank them, tell them what's new and ask a question.
Write down what happens. After each contact, add a line: what you learned and what comes next.
Keep it going
The list isn't finished when you reach 50. Add names as you meet people. Each time you talk with someone on it, ask, "Who else should know about this work?" Review the list once a month and choose the next ten.
Your board can do this exercise too. Fifteen minutes at a board meeting, with each member writing ten names, will add more than you could find alone. More ideas in 9 ways to involve your board in fundraising.
The assignment
Block one hour on your calendar this week. Set a timer, work through the six categories and don't stop until you have 50 names. Then choose your top ten and send the first note before the day is over.
For help deciding who could give at a higher level, see 11 tips for finding major donors for your small nonprofit.
Questions fundraisers ask
What is a prospect list?
A list of people who might give to your organization, with a note on how each one is connected to you. For a small nonprofit it can be a simple spreadsheet with a name, the connection, who knows them best and a next step.
Should I leave off people I don't think can afford to give?
No. Write every name. You don't know what people can give, and you'll guess wrong in both directions. Many generous donors live modestly, and some people give far more than their lifestyle suggests.
What if I can't reach 50 names?
Do the exercise with someone else. A board member, a co-founder or a long-time volunteer will remember people you've forgotten. Going through old event sign-in sheets, email lists and donation records will add more.
What do I do after I have the list?
Sort it by closeness, choose the top ten and contact each one personally within a week. Thank them, tell them what's happening and ask what they think. You're opening a conversation. The ask comes later.
Ask a fundraiser




