Donor Relations
Why Your Year-End Donors Disappear by March
Year-end first-time donors are some of the most promising donors you'll get all year, yet most never give again. The second gift is the hinge, and the first 90 days decide it.

Every January, development staff look at the December numbers and feel good about the new names. Then the year rolls on, and most of those names never show up again.
The data is blunt about this. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 year-end report, retention for new donors (people who gave to an organization for the first time in 2024) was 18.9%. Retention for repeat donors, people with at least one prior year of giving, was 59.3%.
Put another way, if 100 people made their first gift to you last year, about 81 of them didn't give again this year. But once a donor makes it past that first year, the odds flip: roughly 59 of 100 keep giving.
The second gift is the hinge. And for donors who first give in December, the window to earn it is the first 90 days, which is exactly when most nonprofits go quiet.
Year-end donors aren't the problem
It's easy to assume December donors are flaky: they gave because it was the season, or for the tax deduction, and they'd have given to anyone. The data suggests the opposite.
An FEP analysis published by the Association of Fundraising Professionals in 2022 found that donors who made their first gift in November or December had a retention rate 53% higher than donors whose first gift came between January and October. Over 40% of those year-end donors made a second gift, compared with 26% of January-to-October donors. And one in ten year-end donors made a second gift within two months of the first.
So your year-end first-time donors are some of the most promising new donors you'll get all year. Most of them still don't come back.
Why? In my experience, it's mostly what happens next. A donor gives on December 29. They get a receipt in the first week of January (if things go well). Then they're added to the general mailing list and hear nothing personal until the spring appeal, or until next November. From the donor's side, they gave once, got a form letter, and then got asked again. There was never a moment where the organization showed them the gift mattered.
What the first 90 days need to do
A first-time donor has just made a decision about you. The first few months are your chance to confirm it was a good one. That means three things have to happen before you ask for a second gift: the donor feels personally thanked, the donor sees evidence the gift did something, and you learn something about why they gave.
The order matters. Asking before the first two is a mistake I see often. But waiting too long is a mistake too. The FEP finding that one in ten year-end donors gave again within two months tells me some donors are ready earlier than we assume. A well-timed, low-pressure second invitation around week eight or nine is reasonable, as long as the thanks and the proof came first.
A 90-day plan for first-time year-end donors
Imagine a hypothetical adult literacy program with about 600 active donors. This December, 140 people give to it for the first time. Here's how I'd run the next 90 days. The thank-you is tied to each donor's gift date; everything after runs as one group starting Monday, January 4, 2027, which is far easier for a small staff to manage.
Within 48 hours of the gift. Send the receipt and a real thank-you. These can be the same letter, but the thank-you part should sound like a person wrote it and should name what the gift is for. If you need a refresher on why speed matters, here's the 48-hour follow-up rule.
Week 1 (January 4 to 8). Call every first-time donor you have a phone number for. Board members can help. Keep it under two minutes: "Hi, this is Dana from the literacy program. I'm not calling to ask for anything. I just wanted to thank you for your gift in December. It's going toward tutoring for adults learning to read this spring." If you get voicemail, leave the same message. For donors without a phone number, send a short handwritten note.
Weeks 2 and 3 (January 11 to 22). Send a welcome email or letter that tells them what they've joined: one learner's story, one sentence on how the program works, and a single question they can reply to, such as "What made you decide to give this year?" Record the answers in your database. You'll use them for months.
Weeks 4 and 5 (January 25 to February 5). Send the first impact update, tied to the year-end campaign. If the appeal said gifts would fund spring tutoring, report that spring sessions started and how many learners enrolled. Short and specific beats long and polished.
Weeks 6 and 7 (February 8 to 19). Make a non-financial invitation: a tutor open house, a short video from a learner, a volunteer orientation. The point is to give the donor a way to be involved that isn't a gift.
Weeks 8 and 9 (February 22 to March 5). The second invitation to give. For many first-time donors, the most natural ask is monthly giving: "Would you like to make this something you do every month?" Our guide to building a monthly donor program covers how to set that up. Donors who said in their reply that they gave for a specific reason can get a specific ask tied to it.
Weeks 10 and 11 (March 8 to 19). Send a second impact update. Thank anyone who gave a second gift, separately and quickly.
Weeks 12 and 13 (March 22 to April 2). Review the group. Who gave again? Who replied, attended, or opened everything? Who never responded at all? Tag them in your database, and decide who gets moved into your regular stewardship and who gets one more personal touch.
What this is worth
Using the hypothetical literacy program: if its 140 new year-end donors retain at the FEP's average new-donor rate of 18.9%, about 26 of them give again next year. If this plan lifts that to 30%, which is a modest goal and not a promise, 42 come back. That's 16 more second-year donors, and once they've given twice they join the group that retains around 59% of the time. The plan costs a few hours a week for 13 weeks, and the benefit compounds for years.
What to do this month
Before December arrives, decide who owns this plan and put the 13 weeks on a calendar. Write the call script, the welcome letter, and the first impact update now, while you have time to think. Then flag first-time year-end donors in your database so they don't disappear into the general list.
If you want more context on why donors drift away, Why Your Donors Stopped Giving is a good companion read.
The Finish Strong workbook walks through planning a year-end campaign from October through December on a 13-week calendar, with worksheets that build into a complete plan. If you'd like help getting your year-end plan done in time to run a follow-up like this one, take a look at Finish Strong: The 90-Day Year-End Fundraising Plan.
Questions fundraisers ask
Do year-end donors give again?
Most first-time donors don't. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 year-end report put new-donor retention at 18.9%. But an FEP analysis published in 2022 found that donors whose first gift came in November or December retained at a rate 53% higher than donors who started earlier in the year.
What should you do in the first 90 days after a first gift?
Thank the donor and call them, then show what the gift did before you ask again. Decide who owns the plan and put the 13 weeks on a calendar before December arrives.
When should you ask a new year-end donor for a second gift?
Around weeks eight and nine. Invite them to give again, often as a monthly donor.
Ask a fundraiser




