Donor Relations

When Your Fundraiser Leaves, Do Your Donors Leave Too?

When your development director leaves, the donor relationships in their head can walk out the door too. Here's what to do before that day comes, and in the 30 days after.

At a lot of small nonprofits, the most important donor relationships live in one place: your development director's head. Their phone has the cell numbers. Their inbox has the history. They know which donor's husband just had surgery and which one hates being called on Fridays.

Then they take another job, and that knowledge walks out the door with them.

Executive directors often treat a fundraiser's departure as a hiring problem. It's also a donor retention problem, and it starts the day the resignation letter arrives, if not sooner. Here's what to do before that day comes, and in the 30 days after.

Turnover is high, though maybe not "16 months" high

You've probably heard that the average development director stays 16 months. It's been repeated widely, including on this site, so it's worth knowing where it comes from.

The figure traces back to research by Penelope Burk of Cygnus Applied Research. The Chronicle of Philanthropy reported it in April 2012, among preliminary findings Burk presented at an Association of Fundraising Professionals conference from her surveys of fundraisers and nonprofit chief executives. The same report put the direct and indirect cost of replacing a fundraiser at $127,650. Burk's research was later summarized in her book Donor-Centered Leadership. The number is often credited to a 2019 Chronicle of Philanthropy survey, but that survey measured something different.

That 2019 survey, commissioned by the Chronicle and AFP and conducted by the Harris Poll, asked more than 1,000 fundraisers in the U.S. and Canada about their plans. Fifty-one percent said they were very or somewhat likely to leave their current job within two years, and 30% said they were likely to leave fundraising altogether by 2021. In 2013, CompassPoint and the Evelyn and Walter Haas, Jr. Fund's UnderDeveloped study found that half of development directors expected to leave their jobs in two years or less, and executive directors with a vacant development director position said it had been open for an average of six months.

So the 16-month figure is more than a decade old and describes fundraisers broadly, not development directors specifically. I wouldn't put it in a board presentation without that context. But every source points the same direction. If you have one fundraiser, you should plan as though they will leave in the next couple of years and the job will sit empty for months.

Why donors drift when the fundraiser goes

Most donors don't stop giving because they're upset that a staff member left. They stop because the relationship goes quiet. The person who called after every gift, who remembered their grandson's name, who sent the photo from the program they funded, isn't there anymore. Nobody else reaches out. Six months later, the donor gets a generic appeal signed by someone they've never met.

From the donor's side, that feels like the organization forgot about them. In a way, it did.

The fix isn't to keep fundraisers forever, although you should try to keep good ones. The fix is to make sure no important donor knows only one person at your organization.

What to document now, while your fundraiser is still here

Imagine a hypothetical literacy program with a $900,000 budget. Its development director has been there four years and personally manages the 40 donors who give $1,000 or more a year. If she gave notice tomorrow, how much of what she knows about them is written down?

Here's what should be in your donor database, not in someone's head or personal email, for every key donor:

  • Contact details that actually work. Cell phone, preferred email, the best time to reach them, and whether they prefer calls, texts, or letters.
  • Giving history with context. Not just amounts, but why each gift was made, what it funded, and whether it was a response to a specific ask.
  • What they care about. Which program, which story, what first brought them in.
  • Personal details they've shared. Family names, health events, milestones. Only what they've chosen to tell you, recorded respectfully.
  • Open commitments. Pledges, promised site visits, reports they're expecting, anything someone said "I'll get back to you" about.
  • The next planned step. What was supposed to happen next with this donor, and when.
  • Who else knows them. Board members, program staff, or volunteers who have a real relationship with the donor.

Make this part of normal work, not an exit task. Two weeks of notice isn't enough to write down four years of relationships. Ask for contact reports after every meaningful donor conversation, and look at the records yourself once a quarter. If you're new to managing donor relationships at this level, the major donor fundraising guide covers what good donor records look like.

Every key donor should know at least two people

The single most useful thing an executive director can do is make sure every top donor has a relationship with at least two people at the organization. One of them should usually be you.

Pull your top 25 donors. Next to each name, write who besides the development director that donor would recognize and take a call from. If the only name is the fundraiser's, that donor is at risk the moment they leave.

Closing those gaps doesn't take much. Join your fundraiser on a visit. Make a thank-you call yourself after a significant gift. Ask a board member who knows the donor socially to send a handwritten note. A program director inviting a donor to see the work is often more meaningful to the donor than anything from development.

The handoff call and letter

When a fundraiser leaves on good terms, the best handoff is a warm one. Have the departing staff member call or email their key donors before they go, introduce you or their successor by name, and say who will be in touch. Hearing it from someone they trust matters.

Then follow up personally. For your top donors, call first. Something like:

"Hi, Margaret, this is David Chen, the executive director at Maple Street Literacy. I wanted you to hear from me directly that Sarah's last day with us is the 15th. She's been wonderful, and I know she's been your main contact for a long time. I want to make sure nothing changes in how we stay in touch with you. Your gift last spring funded the summer reading program for 60 kids, and I'd love to send you a short update on how it went. Would it be all right if I called again in a few weeks?"

Notice what's missing. There's no ask, no long explanation of why Sarah left, and no promise you can't keep.

For donors you can't reach by phone, send a short letter:

Dear Margaret,

I wanted to let you know personally that Sarah Lopez, who has been your main contact at Maple Street Literacy, is leaving us on the 15th. We're grateful for her work, and I know she's grateful for you.

Your relationship with us doesn't depend on any one staff member. Your gift last spring helped 60 children keep reading through the summer, and I'll make sure you hear how those kids are doing this fall.

Until we've hired Sarah's successor, please reach out to me directly at [phone] or [email]. I'd be glad to hear from you.

With thanks,
David Chen, Executive Director

(The organization and names here are invented for illustration. Use your donor's real gift and real impact.)

The first 30 days after a departure

Week 1: Get access to everything: the donor database, shared drives, and any donor communications in the departing fundraiser's inbox. Make a list of every open pledge, promised report, and scheduled meeting.

Week 2: Call your top donors, starting with anyone who has a pledge or an upcoming commitment. Send the letter to the next tier.

Week 3: Assign each top donor a temporary point person, either you or a board member they know. Make sure every gift during the vacancy still gets a prompt, personal thank-you. It's easy for gift processing to slow down when a position is empty, and donors notice. The 48-hour follow-up rule matters even more when you're short-staffed.

Week 4: Look at what fell through the cracks. Then start writing the job description, and include "inherits documented donor relationships" as something you can honestly promise the next person.

Start before anyone gives notice

If your development director is happy and staying, that's the best time to do this. Pull your top 25 donors this week and write down who else knows each one. Then pick five where the answer is "nobody" and get involved with those donors before the end of the quarter.

For a broader look at why fundraisers leave and what keeps them, see the staff turnover trend.

When you're ready to hire, the development director job description and hiring guide covers the job description, pay, interview questions and the red flags to watch for. And the best protection is a habit of thanking donors from more than one person, so the relationship belongs to your organization and not only to one fundraiser.

Questions fundraisers ask

Do donors stop giving when a fundraiser leaves?

Some do. Most aren't upset that a staff member left. The relationship goes quiet, nobody calls, and they drift.

How do you protect donor relationships from staff turnover?

Record each key donor's contacts, interests, commitments and next step in your database, and make sure every top donor knows at least two people at your organization. One of them should usually be the executive director.

What should you do in the first weeks after a fundraiser leaves?

Get access to the donor database, shared drives and donor correspondence, and list every open pledge, promised report and scheduled meeting. Then call your top donors yourself with an update and no ask.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggeddonor retentionfundraisersrelationshipsstaff turnover

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside