Major Gifts
How to Research and Prepare for a 5-Minute Major Gift Ask
A five-minute ask only works if you've done the work before it. Here's how to learn what a donor can give and what they care about, choose the right project, and walk in ready.

Early in my career, I took several couples on a field trip to see our work. I spent the week with one couple, showing them what we did and the opportunities to help. Nothing seemed to connect with them.
They gave, but less than I'd hoped. Looking back, the problem started before the trip. I hadn't found out whether this work matched their interests.
A five-minute ask sounds easy: frame the opportunity, make the case and ask for an amount. It only works if you know the donor well enough to choose the right opportunity and the right amount. Here's how to prepare. For the ask itself, see the FOCUS method.
1. Understand what they can give
Start with what's in your own file.
- Their giving to you. First gift, largest gift, total giving and whether it's been growing.
- How they give. Gifts of stock, from a donor-advised fund or from an IRA suggest assets beyond a paycheck.
- What you know about their life. Their work, a business they own, property and other boards they serve on.
- Their giving elsewhere. Annual reports and donor lists from other organizations often show giving levels.
Wealth screening tools can add to this. Treat their numbers as estimates. Here are four wealth prospecting tools and a guide to prospect research.
Capacity tells you what's possible. It doesn't tell you what the donor wants to do.
2. Learn what they care about
This is the part I skipped on that field trip, and it matters more than capacity.
What a donor hopes to accomplish with their giving shapes the whole ask. Some donors measure their giving by people helped, and some by a problem solved.
You won't find that in a database. To learn it:
- Read every note in the file.
- Ask colleagues who've met the donor.
- Look at what they've given to, with you and elsewhere.
- Ask the donor. "What first drew you to this work?" "What are you proudest of supporting?" "What would you like to see happen in the next five years?"
If you can't answer "what does this donor care about?" you're not ready to ask. Have another conversation first.
3. Find out who else decides
At one donor meeting several years ago, two people were in the room who managed the money. Many major gifts involve a spouse, a business partner, grown children or an advisor.
Ask early: "When you make a decision like this, is there anyone else you like to include?"
4. Choose the project
Before a donor meeting, I usually have three or four opportunities in mind across different projects, because I'm looking for the one that fits that donor's heart. I also keep "where needed most" available. Some donors would rather trust the organization to use the gift where it will do the most good.
Choose one to lead with. For that one, know:
- What it will accomplish, in terms of people
- The total cost and what a gift at this donor's level would fund
- The timeline and any real deadline
- One story that shows it works
5. Put it on one page
Write a one-page brief for yourself:
- Giving history and largest gift
- What they care about, in their words if you have them
- Who else is involved in the decision
- The opportunity you'll lead with, and two in reserve
- The amount you'll ask for and what it funds
- Likely questions and your answers
- What you'll do if the answer is yes, not now or no
If it doesn't fit on a page, you haven't decided what matters.
6. Rehearse, and pack your bag
Say the ask aloud. Several times, with the amount. Then practice being quiet afterward.
Bring something in writing. At that same meeting, I'd expected a relaxed conversation. After some small talk, the main decision-maker said, "Okay, let's go." He wanted the presentation, and I hadn't brought one. I pulled up our email thread and walked through that. It was embarrassing. A mentor told me afterward to go into every donor meeting ready for both the relationship and the gift. Now I bring a printed proposal or printed materials every time.
Confirm the meeting, and tell the donor you'd like to talk about a specific opportunity.
Mistakes to avoid
- Researching in place of asking. At some point, more research is a way to put off the meeting.
- Assuming capacity means interest. A donor who could give $100,000 won't give it to something they don't care about.
- Showing the donor how much you know about them. Use research to ask better questions. Reciting someone's property records is unsettling.
- Preparing only one option.
- Not writing down what you learned for the next person.
Where to start this week
Choose one donor you hope to ask this quarter. Write the one-page brief. Wherever you have to leave a line blank, that's your next step: a note to read, a colleague to ask or a conversation to have with the donor.
After the ask, here's what to do when donors say no.
Questions fundraisers ask
How much research should I do before a major gift ask?
Enough to answer four questions: what the donor has given, what they could give, what they care about and who else is involved in the decision. For most donors that takes an hour or two. Past that point, another conversation with the donor is worth more than more research.
How do I estimate a donor's giving capacity?
Start with their giving to you: largest gift, total giving and whether it has grown. Add what you know about their work, business or property, and any gifts of stock or from a donor-advised fund. Wealth screening tools can help, but treat their numbers as estimates.
How do I find out what a donor cares about?
Ask them. "What first drew you to our work?" and "What would you most like to see happen in the next few years?" will tell you more than any database. Read past notes too, and ask colleagues who know the donor.
What should I bring to a major gift meeting?
A printed proposal or a one-page summary of the opportunity, with the cost and what a gift would fund. Bring it even when you expect a casual conversation, because some donors will want to go straight to the details.
Ask a fundraiser




