Donor Communication
Should You Send Your Year-End Appeal to Donors Who Just Gave?
Donors who gave this fall are some of the likeliest people on your file to give again, so leaving them out of the year-end appeal usually costs you. Here's who to hold back, and what the letter for everyone else should say.

Every year around this time, someone pulls the list for the year-end appeal and asks a reasonable question: what about the people who gave in October? They just sent a check. Asking again six weeks later feels pushy, so a lot of small shops quietly suppress anyone who gave in the last 60 or 90 days.
I understand the instinct, but I think it's usually the wrong call. Donors who just gave are often among the most likely people on your file to give again. Where organizations get into trouble is sending them the same letter as everyone else, one that reads as if their last gift never happened.
This article covers why recent donors usually belong in your year-end appeal, which ones you should hold back, and what the version they receive should say.
Why suppression feels safe and usually isn't
Suppression feels donor-centered. Nobody wants to be the organization that answers a gift with another request. But look at what it does in practice. A donor who gave on October 20 hears a thank-you, maybe a newsletter, and then nothing during the weeks when many people are deciding where to give.
Recency is one of the strongest signals you have. Someone who gave last month has shown, very recently, that they care about your work and are willing to act on it. Leaving them out means the people closest to giving get the least contact during the busiest giving season of the year.
The national retention data shows why this matters. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's full-year 2025 report, only 18.9% of new donors gave again the following year, compared with 59.3% of repeat donors. Put another way, if 100 people made their first gift to you last year, about 81 of them didn't come back. A first-time donor who gave in October is at the start of that curve. Going quiet on them until spring leaves the relationship to chance.
What the research says about asking too often
The worry about over-asking is legitimate, and there's useful research on it. It just doesn't point where many people assume.
A team at Erasmus University Rotterdam studied whether irritation from charity direct mail reduced giving. They found that more mailings did irritate people, but that the irritation didn't measurably affect stated or actual donations. The authors were careful to note that their test was short and might miss a small effect, so I wouldn't treat it as permission to mail without limit. But it does suggest that "they'll be annoyed and stop giving" is less certain than it feels.
Email looks a little different. Economists Mette Trier Damgaard and Christina Gravert tested reminder emails with a Danish charity (the study was later published in the Journal of Public Economics). Among more than 17,000 people on the warm list, adding one reminder raised the donation rate from 0.35% to 0.53%. It also raised the unsubscribe rate from 2.14% to 3.67%.
On a list of 10,000, that's roughly 18 extra gifts and about 153 extra unsubscribes. The extra ask raised money. The cost showed up somewhere you don't see on the campaign report: people who will never get another email from you.
So the choice is more nuanced than "ask and annoy" versus "don't ask and stay friendly." In mail, the evidence suggests the risk of one more well-made appeal is modest. In email, the cost is real but it lands on your list, not on this campaign. That's an argument for being thoughtful about how many times you email recent donors in December. It isn't a reason to leave them out.
Which recent donors to hold back
Including recent donors doesn't mean everyone gets the same treatment. A few groups deserve their own decision.
Donors who gave in the last two or three weeks. If someone gave on November 28 and your appeal drops December 2, the letter will feel like it crossed in the mail with your thank-you. Hold them for a later wave, or let them get your final December email only.
Your largest donors. If someone gave a significant gift this fall, they should hear from a person, not a mail house. I make that case in more detail in why your top donors shouldn't get your year-end appeal first.
Monthly donors. They need a different letter entirely, because the monthly commitment is the thing you're protecting. Here's how to handle the year-end ask with monthly donors.
Anyone who asked for fewer asks. If a donor told you "once a year, please," honor it. You made them a promise, and it outranks any segmentation plan.
Everyone else who gave this fall should probably get an appeal. They just shouldn't get the same one as the person who last gave 14 months ago.
What the recent-donor version should say
The difference between an appeal that feels pushy and one that feels natural is mostly in the first few lines. A recent donor should be able to tell, immediately, that you know who they are.
Start by acknowledging the gift. Be specific about what it did, or is doing, if you can. For a hypothetical literacy program, that might sound like this:
"Your gift in October is already at work. It's helping cover tutoring for students in our fall reading program, and I wanted you to know that before anything else."
Then make the ask honestly, as something they're free to say no to:
"I'm writing to everyone who supports our students this month, and I didn't want to leave you out. If you're able to give once more before the year ends, your gift will help us start January with a full tutoring schedule. If you've already done what you can this year, thank you. You've made a difference."
That last sentence matters. It gives the donor permission to skip this one without guilt, which makes it easier to receive the letter at all.
A few practical details:
- Adjust the ask amount. Don't base the ask string on a gift they made five weeks ago as if it were their annual capacity. A modest ask, or an open "whatever feels right," often fits better. My piece on choosing year-end ask amounts has more on building ask strings.
- Change the reply device. A line like "Thank you for your October gift" on the reply card reinforces that this is a second, separate decision.
- Cap the email. You might send your general list six or eight December emails. For recent donors, I'd consider fewer, and focus them on the last week of the year.
Run the math on your own file
Here's a hypothetical to make the decision concrete. Imagine a literacy nonprofit with 1,400 active donors. Of those, 220 gave between September 1 and November 15. The development director's instinct is to suppress all 220.
Suppose, for planning purposes, that a version written for these donors gets a 6% response with a $75 average gift, and the mailing costs $1.10 per piece. Those numbers are assumptions, not benchmarks. Use your own history if you have it.
That's about 13 gifts and roughly $990, against $242 in mail costs, for a net of about $750. Not a fortune. But it's a net gain from people who are already paying attention, and some of those 13 donors are now in the habit of giving more than once a year.
If your own numbers suggest recent donors don't respond at year-end, that's useful to know too. You'll have tested it instead of guessing.
Where to start this week
Before your year-end appeal list goes to the printer, pull everyone who gave since September 1. Split them into four groups: gave in the last three weeks, top donors, monthly donors, and everyone else. Decide what each group gets. Then write one new opening paragraph and one new reply card line for the "everyone else" group. That's an afternoon of work, and it turns an awkward ask into a letter that sounds like you know the donor.
If you're still planning the full campaign, my year-end fundraising course walks through how to plan and run a year-end fundraising campaign from start to finish. It's a good fit if you want a clearer process than the one you used last December.
Questions fundraisers ask
Should you send a year-end appeal to donors who gave recently?
In most cases, yes. Recency is one of the strongest signals that someone will give again, so leaving recent donors out usually costs you gifts.
Which recent donors should be held back from the year-end appeal?
Donors who gave in the last three weeks, your top donors, monthly donors and anyone who asked for fewer asks. Each of those groups deserves its own decision.
What should the appeal say to someone who just gave?
Open by acknowledging their recent gift so they can tell right away that you know who they are. Lower the ask, and send them fewer emails than the rest of your list.
Ask a fundraiser




