Mid-level Donors

Should You Visit Mid-Level Donors in Person?

You can't visit every mid-level donor, and you shouldn't try. Here's how to decide who gets a visit, what to do instead for everyone else, and how to prepare so the meeting is worth their time.

Several years ago, I walked into a donor meeting expecting a friendly conversation. I'd talked with the donor by phone, and I believed we were close to done on a commitment. Two people were there who managed the money. After some small talk, the main decision-maker looked at me and said, "Okay, let's go."

He was waiting for me to present the opportunity. I hadn't brought a presentation. I pulled up our email thread about the gift and walked through that. It was embarrassing.

I called a mentor afterward. Her advice was to walk into every donor meeting ready for both kinds of conversation: the relationship and the gift.

That advice matters most with mid-level donors, because you won't get many meetings with them. You can't visit them all, and you shouldn't try. Here's how to decide when a visit is worth it and how to make it count. For the full picture, see the guide to mid-level giving.

Why mid-level donors deserve the thought

Mid-level donors, roughly those giving $1,000 to $10,000 in a year, are the fastest-growing tier in both the Fundraising Effectiveness Project and RKD Group data. They're also where many of tomorrow's major donors come from.

A visit is the most expensive thing you can do for a donor. Spend it where it can change the relationship.

Who gets a visit

Look for these signs:

  • They're at the top of your mid-level range. One step from a major gift.
  • Their giving has gone up. Two or three years of increases is a pattern.
  • They've been with you a long time. Five or more years of steady giving.
  • They've reached out. They replied to an email, called with a question or came to an event.
  • They're nearby, or you'll be in their city for another reason.

A donor with two or three of these belongs on your visit list. Everyone else gets a phone call.

What to do for everyone else

A call or a video chat does much of what a visit does. So does a handwritten note.

Give every mid-level donor a named person to contact and a direct phone number. Many will never use it. They'll still know it's there.

How to prepare

Know their history. First gift, largest gift, what they've given to and any notes from past conversations.

Prepare for the relationship. Have three or four questions ready. How did you first hear about us? What part of the work means the most to you?

Prepare for the gift, too. Before a donor meeting, I usually have three or four opportunities in mind across different projects, because I want to find the one that fits that donor's heart. I keep "where needed most" available as well. Some donors would rather trust us to decide.

Bring something. After that "Okay, let's go" meeting, I started bringing a printed proposal, or at least printed materials or a presentation on my laptop, with the facts and figures ready.

In the meeting

Thank them first, and be specific about what their giving has done.

Ask, then listen. You're there to learn why they give, and you won't find that in a database.

If you make an ask, stop talking and let the donor answer.

Agree on a next step before you leave, even if it's only "I'll send you that report."

After the visit

Write a thank-you note that day. Record what you learned where the next person can find it. Then do what you said you'd do.

Where to start this week

Pull your mid-level donors and mark anyone who meets two of the five signs above. Choose the five closest to you and call each one to say thank you. At the end of the call, ask whether you could buy them a cup of coffee next month.

For more on keeping these donors, see 6 steps to retain more mid-level donors.

Questions fundraisers ask

Which mid-level donors should get an in-person visit?

The ones with signs of greater capacity or commitment: donors at the top of your mid-level range, donors who have raised their giving each year, long-time donors, and anyone who has asked a question or replied to you personally. Start with the ones who live close enough to reach easily.

Should I ask for a gift during a mid-level donor visit?

Not always. A first visit can be about thanking them and learning why they give. But come prepared to talk about a specific opportunity, because some donors expect it. If the conversation turns that way and you're not ready, you've wasted their time and yours.

How many mid-level donors can one person manage?

Far more than a major gift officer can, because most of the contact is by mail, email and phone. Many programs assign several hundred donors to one mid-level officer. Only a small share of those will ever get an in-person visit.

What can I do for mid-level donors I can't visit?

Call them to say thank you, send handwritten notes, give them a named contact with a direct phone number, and send reports with more detail than your general donors receive. A short personal video works well too.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggedmid-levelmidlevel donorsrelationshipsvisits

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside