Trends

Donor Experience: Why the Second Gift Depends on It

Three of four first-time donors never give a second time. The donor experience, from the first thank-you to the first update, is what changes that. Here's how to test yours and fix it.

Donors notice how it feels to give to you: how fast you thank them, whether anyone answers their questions and whether they ever hear what their gift did. That experience decides whether a first gift becomes a relationship.

Right now, for most organizations, it doesn't. The Virtuous 2026 benchmark of 771 nonprofits found that only 25.8% of first-time donors made a second gift in 2025. Three out of four new donors never gave again.

The gap between average and good

The same data shows how much room there is to improve:

  • Across all sectors, 25.84% of first-time donors gave a second gift.
  • Faith-based organizations converted 32.63%.
  • The top quarter of organizations converted 37.9%.

Overall retention held flat at 54.73%. But among the donors who stayed, lifetime value rose 18% and the median gift rose 20%. The donors you keep are worth more every year. The ones you lose in the first few months never get the chance.

The average time between the first and second gift is about 108 days. That's your window.

What changed retention at World Concern

When I joined World Concern, the second-year renewal rate for new donors was about 6%. Almost nobody who gave once gave again the next year.

We didn't find a clever new appeal. We improved what happened after the first gift. We added phone calls to new donors, welcome letters and welcome kits for monthly donors. By the end of the first year, second-year renewal had risen to 22%. By the time I left, it was closer to 30%, and our multi-year renewal rate eventually reached 88%.

Those are things a donor notices. Here's the full story of that turnaround.

Give to yourself once a year

At Food for the Hungry, my team joked that every July they'd get a note from me telling them something was broken. At least once a year, I went through our systems as if I were a new donor. I signed up, made a small gift, emailed the contact address and tested anything that was supposed to happen automatically.

Then I reported what actually happened. Sometimes the welcome series never arrived. Sometimes my email to the contact address never got an answer. The team traced each failure and fixed it. Looking back, I'd do it at least quarterly.

You can't assume a donor process works because a dashboard says it does. Give a gift, and see what you get.

What a good donor experience includes

A fast, personal thank-you. Thank new donors within 48 hours, and make it sound like a person wrote it. Here's the 48-hour follow-up rule.

A welcome series. New donors don't know you yet. A short series of emails that thanks them, shows them the work and tells one story does more than any appeal. M+R's Benchmarks 2026 found welcome series emails get a 1.6% click rate, against 0.59% for standard fundraising email. Here are nine emails you can send in your welcome series.

An update before the next ask. Before you ask a new donor for a second gift, tell them what the first one did. A receipt isn't stewardship. When I make small gifts myself, it's surprisingly common for the experience to end with a receipt and nothing else until the next appeal.

A real person to answer. Make sure your contact form, phone number and reply-to address reach someone who answers within a business day.

A path to give more. Once a donor has given twice, invite them to give monthly. Recurring donors stay. M+R found 71% of monthly donors are still active after a year, against 24% of new one-time donors. See how to start a monthly giving program.

Where to start this week

Make a $10 gift to your own organization from a personal email address. Write down every message you receive for the next 30 days, and how long each took to arrive. Then compare it to what you'd want a new donor to experience. Whatever is missing is your first project.

For the full picture, see the guide to donor retention.

Questions fundraisers ask

What is donor experience?

Everything a donor sees and hears from you after they give: the receipt, the thank-you, the welcome, the reports and how you respond when they contact you.

Why does donor experience matter for retention?

Because most new donors never give again. In the Virtuous 2026 benchmarks, only 25.8% of first-time donors made a second gift, while organizations in the top quartile reached 37.9%. What happens after the first gift accounts for much of that gap.

How do I test my own donor experience?

Make a small gift to your own organization as if you were new, and send a question to your contact address. Write down what arrives and when. Do it at least once a year.

What should a new donor receive?

A prompt, personal thank-you, a welcome letter or email series, a report on what the gift did before the next ask and a clear way to reach a person.

Ask a fundraiser

Still have a question about this?

Taggeddonor experienceengagementfundraisingtrends

About the author

Jeremy Reis

Jeremy Reis is President of Serving Orphans Worldwide and has led nonprofit fundraising for two decades, including growing the World Concern monthly donor program from 800 donors to over 4,000 donors. He is the author of Magnetic Nonprofit and Why We Give, and hosts the Nonprofit Answers podcast.

Learn Fundraising in 10 Minutes

Ten minutes a week. Better fundraising for good.

One practical idea every Tuesday and Thursday from a fundraiser who is raising money right now.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. See what's inside